News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:_why is a role, not a person by killwhitey on Monday January 07, 2013 @09:42AM (#5021132)
>So what makes a zebra a zebra then? I don’t want to get into it, but basically, I take the position that you can’t define something by what it is, you have to define it by what it does.

I like that the author doesn't embarrass himself by attempting to define a Zebra by what it does.

Re:_why is a role, not a person by steveklabnik on Monday January 07, 2013 @09:51AM (#5021171)
Haha. :)

On a more serious note: philosophers who use a process-based ontology/metaphysics would be a little more careful with words: you're defined by your position in given historical processes. Some of these, of course, are initiated by you, hence 'what you do.'

So in the case of a zebra, it's a zebra because it's genesis lies in a historical process: zebras giving birth. If you have two parents who are zebras, then you're a zebra. The first zebras became zebras once they are unable to sexually reproduce with another species, I forget the exact biology term here. For another example, I'm a citizen of the United States because I'm part of a historical process by which people are born in a particular space, both geographical and political, over a certain time period. I don't possess some sort of intrinsic US-ian property.

If you're interested in this kind of thing, Whitehead, Deleuze, and more recently, de Landa (who I adapted the zebra example from) are all materialists who replace identity with process.

Re:_why is a role, not a person by tedkimble on Monday January 07, 2013 @10:13AM (#5021299)
Deleuzian materialists on HN!

Deleuze and de Landa were my primary inspirations during graduate architecture school. I wrote about how such thinking might be incorporated into a web design.[1]

[1]: http://kimble.co/2012/bottom-up-web-design-and-the-materiali...

Re:_why is a role, not a person by steveklabnik on Monday January 07, 2013 @10:33AM (#5021410)
Haha, the soap bubble: yep, that's de Landa alright. Great post, I really enjoyed it.

You know, something about de Landa bothers me a bit, maybe you can chew on this and sometime, we'll discuss it: he wants to "de-postmodernize Deleueze" (even though he's careful that Deleuze isn't pomo, just that he uses dense words), but I'm not entirely sure that you can really separate, say, A Thousand Plateaus from the performative properties of the text. It seems strange to me that a materialist would want to remove the ideas from the primary material that they came from.

That said, he does a damn good job of making it a bit more accessible, especially to technologists.

Re:_why is a role, not a person by davesims on Monday January 07, 2013 @10:15AM (#5021319)
Great references Steve -- also check out Whitehead contemporary Henri Bergson, who I think is criminally overlooked in this category, and a huge influence on Deleuze.
Re:_why is a role, not a person by steveklabnik on Monday January 07, 2013 @10:24AM (#5021366)
Yep, Bergson in general is on my list, but as with anything, it's hard to get through everything: obviously, multiplicity is very important to Deleuze!

I don't have anything specific yet, though: what would you suggest?

Re:_why is a role, not a person by garblegarble on Monday January 07, 2013 @10:09AM (#5021276)
>I forget the exact biology term here

I think "speciation" is the word you're looking for. No idea why I remember that!

Re:_why is a role, not a person by steveklabnik on Monday January 07, 2013 @10:17AM (#5021327)
Yes, when I tried to look that up, I mis-spelled it so poorly that Google couldn't help me out. Thank you.

I feel like there was another related terms, specifically about the point where reproduction can't happen. "genesis" was in there somewhere, I thought. Regardless, thanks.