News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Honey, I Shrunk the TV by mrandish on Thursday October 22, 2026 @06:21PM (#50201888)
Since my other post on AVR trade-offs was getting long, I'm responding to your other points separately here as there are a few things you may find useful to know.

> but I wanted something "simple" for the time being before I do the actual jump to an AVR.

I confess to being an engineer who's worked most of my professional life developing and using digital and analog video/film production tooling but I paused reading that because it's not at all the way I see AVRs and soundbars. Architecturally speaking, AVRs + speakers and integrated soundbars are very nearly identical.

They both take digital signal formats from an HDMI cable and decode the audio portion into analog then send it to either the internal amplifier for output at 'speaker level' on speaker wire or to a pre-amplifier for output on red and white RCA plugs as 'line level'. The difference is the soundbar just bundles the wires and speakers into one opaque box where the speaker wires are hidden, very short and shockingly poor quality. The worst part is you never even have any choices about which wires, which speakers or where they're placed.

That 'sea of red and white jacks' on the back of an AVR may look complicated at first glance but it's actually quite simple and you won't even connect anything to most of them. They're just options in case you ever need them. Example: In our primary home theater system I actually use two AVRs. One is a fairly cheap, newer AVR I bought just to decode the HDMI into analog audio. The second AVR actually drives the 8 main speakers. It's a very high-end Denon from 2002 - so old it doesn't even have any HDMI connectors. The former owner of our house said it was 'too heavy to move' and asked if I'd mind if he just left it. Realizing it was a literally a classic >$4,000 audiophile amp which weighs 70 pounds because it has capacitors the size of Coke cans which sound AMAZING, I couldn't say "YES!!! It's no bother!" fast enough :-). The size and weight of those capacitors is another example of how "Physics Matter" in audio.

> he was able to go to a specialized store where they let him test a myriad of speakers so he could customize the sound "flavor"

Many people aren't aware that "auditioning" speakers in a showroom is almost pointless. The size, proportions and shape of a room can profoundly change the sound of speakers. And the way it changes is also quite counter-intuitive due to how acoustic reflections and standing waves can cause even an 8-inch difference in ceiling height or room width to turn "Amazing" sounding speakers into "Mediocre". Speaker designers use complex modeling software to simulate the exact shape of the resonating cavity inside a speaker because even minute differences can change the sound so much. One way to think about it is that your room is the final speaker and you're sitting inside the 'resonating cavity'. So yeah, it matters.

High-end audiophile stores have long allowed in-home auditions (not that I waste money at those places). But Best Buy type stores will let you return things and many budget audiophile-type, online-only discount speaker companies offer "in-home auditions". I bought my first decent 5.1 system from such an online place over 20 years ago now and I was stunned at how good they sounded for the price. Since speakers must be auditioned in the actual room anyway, the difference between potentially needing to rebox them and drive back to the store or driving to UPS is close to zero. Arguably, a pre-printed label drop-off at UPS is a lot faster than the return line at Best Buy or Magnolia.

In the last ten years esoteric "Speaker Quality" has become almost a non-factor. What I mean is, if we eliminate no-name speakers made solely to hit a dirt cheap price point at someplace like WalMart, and focus on any of the brands regularly mentioned in online forums like r/budgetaudiophile, Worrying about speaker "quality" is wasted effort and focus. Thanks to modern digital design tools and online audio communities quickly praising or dinging the good and bad, all the recommended options are surprisingly good these days. I'm certain that the difference between one decent 'budget audiophile recommended' brand and another for you matters far less than other things like getting enough wattage for your space and speaker placement - like sliding a sub over 10-inches so it's not creating a null standing wave at your listening point.

In recent years, I'm happily now in a place that I could afford just about any gear yet, when we recently built a vacation house, after testing several options, I used in-wall speakers from online-only discount outlet Monoprice. The forums were right. They were shockingly good and met the needs of the room perfectly. I could have easily spent five times more on speakers but any lift in quality would have been negligible.

There are no comments on this comment yet.