News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by inglor_cz on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:46AM (#50182956)
After reading this sentence, I don't trust the author. Misleading as hell.

The success of GLP-1 is based on the fact that the patient can eat less without suffering. No food noise, reduced feelings of hunger, smaller stomach capacity.

Saying that the platitude works is like saying that "just stop doing fentanyl" is the recipe to solve the fentanyl crisis in the US.

Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by stonedivot on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:59AM (#50183179)
But the people claiming that they were some special case that just "couldn't lose weight" no matter how little they ate were bullshitting you. They couldn't handle the suffering, and as such the calorie intake was larger than the calories burned. They wanted you to believe eating less wasn't the solution. The drug proves that it WAS the solution, suffering aside.
Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by howunfortunate on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @12:07PM (#50183315)
"No matter how little they ate" was always ridiculous, obviously everyone knows that literally not eating anything would result in weight loss.

To me personally, the drug proved that people really ARE special cases.

Before Ozempic, I lost about 80 pounds "naturally", by suffering immensely, then kept it off for years, again by suffering immensely. Every day, hunger was at the forefront of my mind all day, every day. It was the #1 concern in my life.

I eventually gained back about 40 pounds, then went on Ozempic.

It has been an eye opener because I now realize what it's like to not suffer from hunger. I realized for the first time that this is how "normal" people feel, all the time! The only way I could get fat now is by eating junk - so in a weird way I started to understand the judgement about being fat.

Some people are just "calibrated" correctly, and that was absolutely mind blowing to me.

Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by Spivak on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @01:20PM (#50184461)
This. 1 Million billion times this. Your story exactly mirrors mine and good heavens I would never loose weight via the suffering route ever again. Losing weight normally I'm in constant pain and literally can't think of anything else-it's all consuming. I do not say this as exaggeration I would rather go through chemo again. At least that you can make the suffering go away sometimes with meds.
Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by faangguyindia on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @07:57PM (#50189272)
When people say, "Dieting doesn't work," they almost never describe their dieting approach. How can all dieting be the same? In the majority of cases, people crash diet; they run an 800–1,000 kcal deficit, lose some weight early on, experience hair shedding and anxiety, weakness etc..., become irritable and miserable, and give up after a few weeks or a month or two. Then they blame dieting. They don't say, "My dieting approach failed," but "Dieting doesn't work." It's like scoring 10/100 on a math exam and saying, "Math doesn't work." Brother what? Everyday math is being by people with lot of success. Dieting is being used by MMA pros for weight cuts, natural bodybuillders, actors, models, 100s of thousands of ordinary people on fitness subs like r/caloriedefict r/naturalbodybuilding r/CICO

Very few people accept that maybe there is a flaw in their dieting. There are experienced people who study this stuff for years; how can I, as a newbie, learn all this in a short period of time, fail, and claim that dieting doesn't work?

Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by IncreasePosts on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @12:26PM (#50183614)
What percent of obese people were saying that? Who exactly are you arguing against?
Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by inglor_cz on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @01:11PM (#50184335)
"suffering aside."

This is precisely the thing that cannot be put aside without making the solution much less useful / efficient / solution-esque.

Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by dualvariable on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @01:29PM (#50184580)
Different people experience different levels of suffering.

I just started on a GLP-1, and it has already been an interesting lesson in the subjective nature of food drives and hunger.

I've heard for literally years the advice "just drink some water it will trick you into feeling less hungry".

And I've always suspected this was some bullshit placebo, because that OBVIOUSLY doesn't work (so I thought). Water doesn't replace food, it just fills up your stomach so that eating becomes somewhat more unpleasant. But the food/hunger drive is still there unabated.

Well, except after taking a GLP-1 I actually experienced the sensation of drinking something and having my hunger go down. Whatever that circuit is, it has been broken in me for at least my entire adult life. So giving me that advice had been like trying to explain the color to a blind person.

Which, oddly, ties a lot more into the subject title than the example the author gave...

Re:Most advice is right for the person giving it by faangguyindia on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @08:13PM (#50189404)
>The success of GLP-1 is based on the fact that the patient can eat less without suffering.

Suffering comes not from "dieting" but from not knowing calorie math and using too big of a deficit!

Run too big of a deficit = become miserable = blame dieting and stop halfway. Simply pick a deficit you can continue for long; it's the solution! Average woman may have TDEE around 1800-2000, she can eat 1700-1600kcal comfortably.

You know that if i remove 150kcal from your diet, your wouldn't notice? that's like 2 slices of bread. So the hunger suppression will never be a question for vast majority of fat people

150kcal deficit over a year = 7.1kg or 15.6 lbs lost! and 300kcal = 31.2lbs or 14.2kg!! all this without any injection or drug without any exercise or severe loss of lean masss