Ask HN: being offered stocks, how to estimate value?
I am consulting local start up on some specific technical issues. I am charging quite a lot to do more work on this start up, so I was offered stocks as a part of payment. But I have no idea how to evaluate this offer. Any tips on what I should look for and what I should base my numbers on?
(
8 comments
| 4 points
| on HN
)
YES: Google can tell you; NO: $0.
If you get equity from a startup, your expected value is nil, or near enough to be without distinction. Either the equity is utterly dilute, or the founders are incompetent. Neither case looks like getting paid to me.
Keep in mind that equity reflects possibilites, specially in startups. I would say that most of the value of a startup are just changes of succeeding. Read: How much does a lottery ticket is valued?
Second, more useful:
You need choose a target P/E ration, and calculate. PE == Share_value / Earnings_per_share.
30 is a reasonable target. The problem is, in tech you can get P/Es around 200-300 (which is stupid).
But really, there is no reasonable way for you to value their offer. I would take cash and possibly offer a payment plan instead.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/02/technology/for-founders-to...