News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Awakening (during anesthesia) by jrockway on Saturday January 05, 2013 @10:36PM (#5015165)
This seems to be a scare piece rather than a scientific article. For one thing, every mention of a drug inevitably has some irrelevant quip about it, like "... always accomplished with propofol, a drug now famous for killing Michael Jackson. It is milky and viscous, almost like yogurt in a fat syringe." Scary. Drugs should be clear and should not have ever killed anyone even when intentionally misused. (I'm surprised they didn't mention that the doctors drank water before the procedure, a chemical that everyone who has ever died drank until their bodies were three quarters full of it!)

Regarding the anecdote about the dental surgery study, I am personally not surprised by the results. When I was having my wisdom teeth removed, one of my anesthesia options was to be put to sleep for the procedure. The doctor said that the sleep would be like taking a nap, and the purpose of being asleep wasn't to prevent any pain (I would immediately awaken if other anesthesia was not used and they started pulling out the teeth), but rather so that I wouldn't be anxious about the procedure. With this in mind, it seems perfectly reasonable that patients in the study would remember strange occurrences while they were asleep. They probably woke up because of the commotion and went back to sleep after things were back to normal, not remembering much consciously. I would bet that if a study were done where volunteers were asked to sleep on an airline flight until they reached the gate at their destination and were interviewed under hypnosis a bit later, they would probably remember things like the announcement to put away electronic devices. They might not remember that normally, however, kind of like how you forget dreams after you wake up. (Well, I do anyway.)

Ultimately, the subject matter that the article covers is extremely important and interesting, but I thought the negative overtones were not proportional the actual risk of waking up during surgery and experiencing a lifetime of emotional pain as a result. People already irrationally weigh risks when considering surgery, and I don't think this piece will help them make a more rational decision.

There are no comments on this comment yet.