News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why people keep posting AI-generated projects aro... by krapp on Sunday October 18, 2026 @07:14AM (#50139990)
AI generated code isn't FOSS. No human created anything, no human understands the code (because no human wrote it,) and no human will learn from or edit the code, or even bother reading it. It will only ever be interacted with indirectly through a closed-source and proprietary code generating service, and actual human knowledge and experience will be lost. This is antithetical to everything FOSS stands for.
Re:Ask HN: Why people keep posting AI-generated projects aro... by runningmike on Sunday October 18, 2026 @07:24AM (#50140048)
“ AI generated code isn't FOSS” Foss is just a license on software code. Do not make a Foss license bigger than what it is. Just do not do this… Even AI slob under a Foss license meets the four core freedoms based on definitions from the Free Software Foundation.
Re:Ask HN: Why people keep posting AI-generated projects aro... by krapp on Sunday October 18, 2026 @07:32AM (#50140109)
>Foss is just a license on software code.

No it isn't. It's a culture and an ethos and vibe-coders are ruining it because they don't understand it. You're the sociopaths in the "geeks,MOPs and sociopaths" cycle[0].

>Even AI slob under a Foss license meets the four core freedoms based on definitions from the Free Software Foundation.

The culture of AI use doesn't, because AI enjoyers don't want to allow humans to exercise those freedoms without an LLM as a middleman. These freedoms only matter when they're exercised by humans without gatekeepers. Especially without closed source government gatekeepers.

To say nothing of the fact that LLMs don't respect those licenses when generating code, anyway.

[0]https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths

Re:Ask HN: Why people keep posting AI-generated projects aro... by runningmike on Sunday October 18, 2026 @07:55AM (#50140293)
Agree upon that most people who know the difference between foss and oss have some ethical principles not captured in the formal license text.

By default gatekeepers should be distrusted since gatekeepers are seldom organised as open projects that can be replaced in a simple way.

There is no such thing as a AI culture. There are imho big tech AI companies that disrespect all ethical norms and legal rules in all ways. We need to create a real open alternative that is better in every aspect. Real open lllms are scare and can and will never compete with $$$$ shitware llms.

I advocate for free and open ML/AI. I dislike the fact that my code (foss)and text(cc-by) are used by all LLMs without respecting the licenses..And yes slob AI code is seldom useful to build upon as human…

Re:Ask HN: Why people keep posting AI-generated projects aro... by verdverm on Sunday October 18, 2026 @10:20AM (#50141338)
How do you know the LLM used your code and not some other project?

Which aspect of the licenses have they not complied with?

Re:Ask HN: Why people keep posting AI-generated projects aro... by Eliah_Lakhin on Sunday October 18, 2026 @03:31PM (#50144479)
I want to add that AI-generated code isn't FOSS because it's not a _source_ code at first place. This is a generated code. All other reasons, in my opinion, are secondary and may change over time.

Publishing generated code is not unique for AI. For example, it's a common practice to generate a parser using YACC from source grammar files, and then publishing both. The main thing here is that no one claims that this code is a "source code", no one saying that it has been written by someone. It is perfectly fine to put a comment directly in the file's text that it has been generated by YACC.

If people would be more accurate on this matter, and wouldn't publish generated code alongside with OSS projects, a notable part of the problems we discuss today wouldn't exist.