News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lean Now Ships with Verified Kernels by anonymous908213 on Saturday October 17, 2026 @11:54PM (#50137780)
Make a trivial adjustment to your final proposition and it would still hold, no?

> Humans have quite a bit of creativity but make a lot of mistakes. The Lean typecheck never makes a mistake but has no creativity. Get them to work together in an iterative loop and you get what we have now.

Re:Lean Now Ships with Verified Kernels by AxEy on Sunday October 18, 2026 @12:03AM (#50137812)
The speed matters massively. Also it seems that LLMs are... getting to be quite creative.

The point is that the there has to be an idea to try to check. Lean does not give you that.

Re:Lean Now Ships with Verified Kernels by altmanaltman on Sunday October 18, 2026 @12:42AM (#50137981)
But a human being using LLMs will be much more creative than just LLMs alone right? Or does the human reduce the creativity in this system in your opinion?
Re:Lean Now Ships with Verified Kernels by eru on Sunday October 18, 2026 @03:55AM (#50138924)
> Or does the human reduce the creativity in this system in your opinion?

Yes. Humans are slow.

Re:Lean Now Ships with Verified Kernels by AxEy on Sunday October 18, 2026 @12:49AM (#50138003)
> But a human being using LLMs will be much more creative than just LLMs alone right?

I believe so. But the question I was responding to was whether humans working with Lean would be have been more creative.

Re:Lean Now Ships with Verified Kernels by rcxdude on Sunday October 18, 2026 @08:41AM (#50140594)
It's less useful, because humans make fewer mistakes and take longer to turn their thoughts into Lean. I think most mathematicians have a higher success rate thinking about the problem informally, poking at it themselves, then formalizing it iteratively to make it more watertight as they gain confidence in the idea.
Re:Lean Now Ships with Verified Kernels by dnautics on Sunday October 18, 2026 @02:10PM (#50143702)
> humans make fewer mistakes

Is this empirically measurable?