News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The "well-calibrated interviewer" curse by tptacek on Saturday January 05, 2013 @02:20PM (#5013670)
Company pays everyone comparable amounts of money. Company demands a basket of different deliverables that are (a) not comparably pleasurable to generate and (b) not comparably important to the company when seen through the lens of employee rewards. Company starts with the premise that all employees will share the load on the whole basket, but later looks at performance on deliverables to allocate specific employees for specific deliverables.

Result: all rational incentive is to do a terrible job on those deliverables that are least pleasant and/or least rewarded.

It's a simple point. I'm surprised you missed it.

Re:The "well-calibrated interviewer" curse by nostrademons on Saturday January 05, 2013 @03:26PM (#5013916)
The effective response to that is to say "I'll do a good job on this task, but I can't do it all the time, because I have other important tasks to get down." Save the passive-aggressiveness for when the company disrespects your "No".

There're many other tasks like this - usually the reward for being good at your work is to get more work. And the way out isn't to be shitty about doing your work, it's to ask for what you want in return for doing well at your work. That could be a raise, or the freedom to work on interesting projects of your own choosing, or more personal time, or it could just be "I don't want to do interviews this quarter so I can focus on my professional goals".

I think there's a legit problem at Google in that interviewing isn't rewarded highly come performance review time, so it doesn't translate into bigger raises or better projects. But there're mechanisms in place for saying "Please don't send me interviews" or blocking off days where you won't be scheduled for one. If the best interviewers take advantage of them and then HR finds out that there's a shortage of good interviewers, that sends a strong signal to the company that they need to increase the rewards for interviewing.

Re:The "well-calibrated interviewer" curse by rheide on Sunday January 06, 2013 @06:21AM (#5016031)
To tell you the truth, I didn't miss it, but I thought it was worth pointing out that without including the comparison against colleagues, it would be a different situation. You are of course right that it's not right to treat colleagues differently, especially if some of them are also 'well-calibrated'. An incentive program would've been a better solution that a penalty system, perhaps.