Would you be able to circle these highlights? I viewed
- https://jakearchibald.com/c/original-CXtAofvc.jpg
- https://jakearchibald.com/c/avif-q39-e0-d8-yuv444-ssimu70.4-...
at 100% magnification at peeped around for a few minutes but didn't notice anything. Maybe my eyes / monitor is bad...
Oh crap, it's this image
https://jakearchibald.com/2020/avif-has-landed/demos/compare...
I was talking about. He linked another one! Guess people finally realized that one sucks and now they have a new one. I screwed up.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @01:49PM
(#50121786)
They didn't even have the halo back then!
Look at the fuel cap, the green part of the front wheel, or the vertical frame split behind the fuel cap. AVIF smooth the details out too much.
I'm looking as closely as I'm able, and I don't see what you mean. (I'm not a car guy, or a photo guy.) What do you mean by highlights? What am I looking for? Reflections?
Look between the Eni and ApeCoin logos. In lossless you can see there are lines from what I assume separate pieces assembled together. Next to ApeCoin there's also a round piece in the lossless version which is missing from the AVIF. JPEG XL loses most of these as well though.
That's what I noticed anyway, not a car or photo guy either.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @02:41PM
(#50122556)
The original is a single photo.
If you are referring to "lines from what I assume separate pieces assembled together." I didn't mean that the photo was assembled from multiple pieces, I meant that part of car was (panels or similar). Those lines between panels were no longer visible.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @03:16PM
(#50123103)
Oh, yeah, haha!
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @01:29PM
(#50121525)
I agree fwiw. The only one that looks bad to me is jixel at lower qualities.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @01:39PM
(#50121658)
OH WAIT. I KNOW WHAT'S HAPPENING HERE.
You're looking at it in a browser that doesn't support JPEG XL, so it's falling back to a WASM renderer, and I think it handles resizing differently.
This is totally my bad. I thought I was doing a good thing by adding that fallback renderer, but it isn't identical and it's giving people the wrong impression.
The lossless version is JPEG XL, hence the difference to AVIF.
by the way, why not convert everything to png for comparisons to avoid browser support issues?
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @02:52PM
(#50122725)
All browsers support AVIF and JPEG XL now. I was hoping to keep their download size benefits.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by D2OQZG8l5BI1S06 on Friday October 16, 2026 @03:26PM
(#50123254)
Firefox added support only 3 days ago! And this doesn't cover the ESR version.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @05:04PM
(#50124688)
Sure but this is a technical post aimed at a technical audience.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by bigstrat2003 on Friday October 16, 2026 @07:26PM
(#50126136)
None of which means you should expect your audience to have a new version which came out three days ago. Lots of technical people stay behind the bleeding edge for very good reason.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @10:15PM
(#50127236)
This is why I added the wasm fallback. The question was why I didn't serve PNGs to everyone.
What's the liktlyhood of ~~a technical~~ any audience being 4 days behind on updates? (hint: very high)
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by qingcharles on Saturday October 17, 2026 @01:36AM
(#50128267)
Not me keeping Chrome open for two months with "New Chrome available" badge in the corner.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by queenkjuul on Saturday October 17, 2026 @10:54PM
(#50137454)
My 58 Firefox tabs that get updated once every 30-60 days when i reboot my desktop lolol
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by CodesInChaos on Friday October 16, 2026 @04:54PM
(#50124537)
In Firefox 157.0.1, the right border of the image moves by a pixel or two when I press "hold for lossless" while viewing the AVIF. I think it's the lossy AVIF that's a bit too small.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by jaffathecake on Friday October 16, 2026 @05:22PM
(#50124953)
That's what I'm talking about. JXL support landed in 158.
Re:JPEG XL vs. AVIF for web use-cases
by CodesInChaos on Friday October 16, 2026 @05:34PM
(#50125067)
But why does missing JXL support make the AVIF too small? It ends one pixel before the gray background.
Granted, AVIF performs impressively for, say, a huge hero image for a blog where you're out to create an overall impression and people aren't going to look at it closely. It does not impress me when I am compressing photos I took with my mirrorless and I expect them to look like photos taken with a mirrorless and not cell phone snaps.