News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Roadster by estearum on Friday October 16, 2026 @07:46AM (#50117230)
Operating margin fell from 16% to ~2% over the last 10 years and will probably be negative in 2026 and 2027. They have a big cash pile to burn through but they’re spending it on ummm “a flying car,” humanoid robots, and an AI fab. They’re fucked.
Re:Tesla Roadster by funcDropShadow on Friday October 16, 2026 @08:53AM (#50117767)
Similar, to the time Tesla was fucked, because they wanted to sell EVs when there was neither demand nor charging infra. Or when SpaceX wanted to build a rocket that could land on legs, whereas every wannabe rocket scientists knew that to be impossible.
Re:Tesla Roadster by estearum on Friday October 16, 2026 @09:43AM (#50118321)
Or similar to the time Cybertruck was a giant success, FSD was ready in 2022, and Falcon 1 would launch 600kg for $7 million.
Re:Tesla Roadster by queenkjuul on Friday October 16, 2026 @07:48PM (#50126319)
Don't forget the roadster from 2017 which has taken nine years and counting to evolve into something not remotely like what was promised
Re:Tesla Roadster by funcDropShadow on Monday October 19, 2026 @07:42AM (#50151157)
Yes, Elon's time tables are very aggressive. But that is by design. And FSD is here, although it took much longer than anticipated, no competitor caught up.
Re:Tesla Roadster by vessenes on Friday October 16, 2026 @09:03AM (#50117882)
I'd be very surprised if the roadster project was particularly expensive. That operating margin tells you they are spending all the cash they are earning on cars on the other stuff, not that the cars suddenly became more expensive to make.

I'm interested to meet someone online who's short both on-shore US silicon fabs and the market for humanoid robots. Can you say more about your thinking?

Re:Tesla Roadster by estearum on Friday October 16, 2026 @09:38AM (#50118270)
I'm short on an allegedly successful automotive company that has a rapidly deteriorating automotive business (due entirely to management's own decision-making) pivoting into the most hyped business ideas in the world. I'm bearish on the type of creative accounting and self-dealing we see between the Musk companies.

Musk is similar to Zuck in that they get some credit for sheer courage to turn the wheel on their massive businesses, but they also have to be right. Aside from his anticompetitive behavior, Zuck continues to miss. Musk's pattern has been that the more Musk is personally involved, the worse the outcomes. Cybertruck was his baby. Optimus is his baby.

If Tesla is doing so well as an automotive business, then why doesn't he just continue making it a great automotive business?

Re:Tesla Roadster by vessenes on Friday October 16, 2026 @11:25AM (#50119577)
I mean the short answer is that it doesn’t temperamentally suit him to do so.

Maybe a mid length answer is if you agree with his assessment on say humanoid robots in terms of market and you believe they might have a geometric growth factor in production (eg robots can make more robots) then you’d want that business build out done by a team that can scale rapidly.

For fabs spacex and Tesla are significant consumers of the output- vertical integration is preferred by lots of companies.

Re:Tesla Roadster by estearum on Friday October 16, 2026 @11:29AM (#50119647)
> I mean the short answer is that it doesn’t temperamentally suit him to do so.

Correct, and I think having a CEO who's totally unaccountable to a board and is temperamentally unable to focus on his core business is not good.

SpaceX and Tesla are nowhere near large enough consumers to justify vertically integrating a fab. The demand is predicated on Optimus producing millions of units per year.

This circularity will probably end up being seen in retrospect as so transparently absurd that it'll beggar belief that anyone accepted it.

Re:Tesla Roadster by vessenes on Friday October 16, 2026 @12:58PM (#50121020)
I respect the perspective, of course, and cannot argue with the risk assessment.

That said I think these bets will pay off. Let’s check in in five years!

Re:Tesla Roadster by krisoft on Friday October 16, 2026 @03:11PM (#50123024)
> Let’s check in in five years!

Do you have particular predictions we can evaluate in five years?

Re:Tesla Roadster by vessenes on Friday October 16, 2026 @04:07PM (#50123861)
1) The fab will have been a highly profitable investment, possibly worth spinning out

2) more than 1mm optimus produced and sold in the US

Happy for any counters :)

Re:Tesla Roadster by estearum on Friday October 16, 2026 @04:21PM (#50124059)
In five years? It would be an achievement if it's operating in five years. Absolutely zero chance it will be profitable by then.

1MM Optimus sold in the US is hilarious too.

Want to make bets on these?

Re:Tesla Roadster by TheOtherHobbes on Friday October 16, 2026 @06:44PM (#50125786)
I'm not a betting man, but I'd comfortably place a bet to agree with you.

My prediction is Musk will become less and less stable, more and more flamboyant and performative, and less and less effective.

He's already saying he suffers from occasional AI psychosis, and there is no chance that's going to get better on its own.

Re:Tesla Roadster by vessenes on Sunday October 18, 2026 @11:12PM (#50147951)
Hmm, I mean I'll post up on longbets - sure.

Terafab profitability is really tough to get right, I'm open to ideas -- there's operating profit, operating profit net of amortization / depreciation, there's like six phases of the terafab specced out running through 203X (and as you say, slippage is inevitable there). I'd want to be considered a winner if the value of the EUV machines is up significantly, e.g. it was a balance sheet winner.

Send proposals.

Re:Tesla Roadster by HarHarVeryFunny on Friday October 16, 2026 @06:02PM (#50125338)
You've got to take Musk's forecasts with a massive grain (sack?) of salt. Pre-launch he was estimating making 250,000 Cybertrucks per year by 2025. So far, total sales over 3 years have actually been 60-70K.

I'd bet that in 5 years time Optimus total sales are in the 10's of thousands at best, with few to no large scale industrial users (other than self-use by Musk). Customers will be similar to what AgiBot and Unitree currently have - entertainment, hospitality, academic, small scale trials, plus a few Tesla fanboy sales that don't do anything actually productive.

Re:Tesla Roadster by vessenes on Sunday October 18, 2026 @11:16PM (#50147974)
On the cybertruck, I was going to suggest that's a function of demand, but actually I see there are substantial wait times for these. That might mean they cut factory capacity though, I haven't tracked it super carefully.

If Optimus is in use at factories in 2029 then it will absolutely be able to produce more than a thousand robots a month by the end of 2031, just using any sort of geometric production curve as a swag.

As to users, I think if it can provide home services, they're going to sell a ton of them.

As to Elon's forecasts, yes, double them at least. And, also, he's mostly right historically, if delayed substantially. I think there's near infinite demand for $1/hr robot labor in the US.

Re:Tesla Roadster by ChrisGreenHeur on Friday October 16, 2026 @03:57PM (#50123727)
It will be his robot typing the message for him at that point
Re:Tesla Roadster by sebastos on Saturday October 17, 2026 @10:33AM (#50131548)
It’s so interesting. On the one hand you have our culture’s deserved rancor at late stage capitalist CEOs juicing the profits and squeezing every last drop of profit out of their customers. Tired derivative products and enshittified service models are exhausting us. Our institutions seem to be creatively bankrupt, and every single product and utterance they make has been through 500 different committees to ensure maximum profitability and minimum soul. We all fucking hate what almost corporate America has come to stand for.

And yet… when it’s Elon Musk’s company, we are suddenly all numbers and figures, and we waggle our fingers disapprovingly that he doesn’t have board approval. Yes, with Musk you have a childish huckster asshole. And increasingly it does appear he’s gone off the deep end, buying into his own self mythology. But the one redeeming quality he still demonstrates is refusal to settle for doing the same thing over and over. He continually and unreasonably pushes the envelope.

Tesla has definitively become a successful company. They defied all the naysayers in reaching that success, and it has turned into a global behemoth. They have oodles of money. The fact that Musk tirelessly insists on trying new moonshots that seem ridiculous is a GOOD thing - it’s the thing we _lack_. Inventive, audacious risk-taking is exactly what our stupid extractive scam economy lacks. Compared to you and me, yes, Musk is a cringey edgelord with the energy of a weird kid at the sleepover who tells bragging lies. But compared to his cohort who run large businesses, he is a goal oriented doer who attracts great talent and then relentlessly pushes them to achieve the impossible. And they actually succeed some non-zero amount of the time. It doesn’t matter that not every idea is a winner. That’s not how moonshots work. The point is that _some_ moonshot ideas do work though and actually move us up the tech tree. And the probable reality is that the delusional unrealistic asshole _helps_ push you there, precisely because they cannot be reasoned with. No, you cannot build moonshot companies without grandiosity, because the people working on it need to have a mission that is bigger than dollars and cents or common sense. If the only thing pushing you is good financials, you will quit as soon as “projections” start to look bad. In the area of moonshots, projections are just the opinions of uninformed non-believers who will ALWAYS mount until the world convinces you to stop working on the “stupid” thing.

All that said, the flying car is the dumbest thing I’ve seen him push and I don’t find it remotely exciting. Self-driving and robots are way cooler.

Re:Tesla Roadster by estearum on Saturday October 17, 2026 @11:53AM (#50132176)
I don't really disagree with much here. I think Musk is a despicable piece of shit for reasons totally outside of his management track record.

However, the root of this conversation is not about Musk at all but about whether Tesla's core business (automotive) is in trouble. The answer to that, as Musk is demonstrably convinced as well as I am, is "yes."

Then we get into Musk's own personal idiosyncrasies and to what degree they're a liability or an asset to pull Tesla away from doom. For the reasons you mention, they're an asset. Not many leaders are willing to throw the wheel like he is (Zuck being another example). For other reasons, his idiosyncrasies are a liability. Like the fact that he personally was single-handedly responsible for destroying huge amounts of Tesla's brand power and that his personal project (the Cybertruck) inflicted such gargantuan direct and indirect cost on Tesla at such a critical moment.

Again, the question is whether Tesla's core business is in trouble. The answer is yes. Nobody remarks that it's such an incredible thing that a CEO of an unambiguously crushing-it company is willing to yolo the company into new directions.

Re:Tesla Roadster by sebastos on Monday October 19, 2026 @12:46PM (#50154648)
Yeah - I guess not much I disagree with here. But, some food for thought: people on this website have been telling me Uber is going to fail for nigh on 10 years now. Constantly, breathlessly, they've explained to me it's NOT because they feel any one way about the misogynistic leadership elements at that company. No, they predict it will fail purely based on a dispassionate reading of the financials and fundamentals. It will definitely fail _because_ it's a bad company. Any day now, they assure me.

Point being: phrases like 'rationalization' and 'wishful thinking' exist for a reason. You should be extremely skeptical of how fairly you are assessing the prospects of a company run by people you hate. You are almost definitely interpreting the outlook uncharitably.

Re:Tesla Roadster by WalterBright on Sunday October 18, 2026 @12:58AM (#50138040)
> our culture’s deserved rancor at late stage capitalist

Late stage capitalism was coined over a century ago. It still hasn't happened.

What does happen, however, is a company will grow until it strangles itself with committees and bureaucracy. And then gets replaced with a younger company. A good book on this is "The Innovator's Dilemma".