Re:Rant: Backbone, Angular, Meteor, Derby
by blissofbeing on Friday January 04, 2013 @02:51PM
(#5009427)
I have found the Angularjs community to be thriving and most helpful. Check out their google group (1), g+ page (2), g+ community (3), irc room (4) and youtube channel (5) for an excellent place to get help. I usually get help as soon as I need it, amazing.
Also I have been impressed with the active community projects AngularStrap (6) and AngularUI (7)
1) https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/angular
2) https://plus.google.com/110323587230527980117/
3) https://plus.google.com/communities/115368820700870330756
4) http://webchat.freenode.net/?channels=angularjs&uio=d4
5) http://www.youtube.com/user/angularjs
Re:Rant: Backbone, Angular, Meteor, Derby
by tomsaffell on Friday January 04, 2013 @03:14PM
(#5009584)
We recently faced a similar decision, and ultimately went with angular - the two-way binding sold it for me, plus the concept of pushing all DOM manipulation into directives (declared in the HTML), to get that out of the controllers. We've spent ~8 weeks using it: our codebase is smaller, easier to mantain/adapt, and better modularized -- we love angular. The docs are great, and the IRC community is there when you hit something quirky.
I always said it, Backbone is not a JSMVC Framework; It's a JSMVC Framework Framework (How to go meta!) Basically, it's a solid foundation to create a JSMVC Framework.
However, as our Backbone application grew in complexity, we noticed that Backbone is so bare in terms of functionalities that we had to build our own half-baked framework on top of it to make up for the gaps.
I think the Backbone project needs to make Backbone's intentional feature sparseness clear. I've come to realize that backbone is more of a library which provides a basis to make a client-side framework rather than a something that can be used standalone by app developers.
If I could go back and change our original choice, I definitely would have gone with one of the Backbone-derived frameworks (chaplin, marionette) or just gone with something more fully-featured like angular. While backbone is beautiful and elegant for small projects, it just doesn't provide much convenience as a stand-alone library for larger applications.