News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by bowsamic on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:12AM (#50069364)
Agreed. LLMs are really bad at software engineering at the moment and those who disagree are those people who think more lines of code are good. The only argument against it is the unjustified guess that one day they’ll be better. My feeling is that they very fact they show us things we missed makes them liable to increase tech debt, and that they in general reduce human understanding of the code base. I don’t see how those things will ever not be true
Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by vbezhenar on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:19AM (#50069416)
I've found that LLM helps me to write good code. It essentially works like a colleague who can review my code. It spotted many issues which I wouldn't spotted before. It also helps to free me from some mundane work.

In the end, my immediate productivity with LLM is a lot lower than before. But I assume that quality is a bit higher, at least in the long run, because issues fixed early saves a lot of time later.

I guess I don't use LLMs like a lot of other people. In fact I continue to write most code myself and I just use LLM to aid me or to generate something that's very similar to existing entity and just requires careful copy&paste&replace. My only fear is that this approach to work is not very popular and I might be asked one day to switch to wipe code, which I don't enjoy at all.

Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by bkaae on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:20AM (#50069430)
This is just not true. LLMs are good at some development.

You may caveat what type of software you are talking about, like complex or out-of-the-ordinary, and say that llms are still bad at that. Fine. But LLMs are actively being used for developing thousands of websites all the time - you can see several examples of them on hackernews every week.

Amount of lines is irrelevant when talking about a landing page or a huge number of internal tools that people are building at the moment. At least until a certain point.

Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by ThunderSizzle on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:30AM (#50069521)
Building a landing page is not something you require a software engineer for.

Any programmer should be able to hack one up. LLMs are good at _programming_, but I haven't seen evidence they are good at engineering yet. But then again, many people with the title "software engineer" are not great at it either.

Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by bkaae on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:25AM (#50084211)
I wholeheartedly agree with this.

Engineering normally requires thinking long term and if you want to use LLMs it needs to be way more structured. For this use-case LLMs are on way more shaky ground.

Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by bowsamic on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:24AM (#50069483)
Well you’re just saying here you don’t care about tech debt or software quality. Of course lines of code is relevant, it’s generally bad to add code and makes the software harder to maintain. I would agree that software development standards in web development can be poor though
Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by bkaae on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:22AM (#50084187)
Yes that's true - for a lot of use cases I don't care about software quality.

When pouring concrete, I'm not going to use expensive hardwood to frame the concrete base, I'm gonna use stuff that's just strong enough. It's going down the bin anyway.

A lot of internal tools are fine if they are just good enough, they don't really need to be that maintainable if 2 people are gonna use it every once in a while

Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by suttontom on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:41AM (#50072502)
Thousands of websites like Garry Tan's amateur pile of garbage?
Re:Were Software Engineers blue-collar workers all along? by bkaae on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @04:23AM (#50084204)
No.. Like my barbers new website is great and he used AI for it.

Or like the internal tool I whipped up in a few days to try out how we can structure some specific data we have internally in our company.