Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen...
by dllthomas on Friday January 04, 2013 @08:59AM
(#5007592)
I... think you miss the parent's point, which is that the features a social network provides to an individual user aren't just technological. The point is connecting people to other people and almost always that means to specific other people, and if those specific other people aren't on the new network that's not a feature the new network provides until they migrate, and that's not something you can fix with just tech (except maybe by automating crossposts? hmm...)
Edited to add: Joining a social network is, therefore, adding features (when viewed through this lens) without doing any coding.
Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen...
by shmerl on Friday January 04, 2013 @11:58AM
(#5008475)
Yes, in such way just the mere fact of joining has a side consequence of increasing user base. But in most cases those who join and don't participate are often not reading the network as well, since they have no connections there (they aren't following tags or have contacts and etc). So real help for the network are participating users.
Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen...
by dllthomas on Friday January 04, 2013 @05:11PM
(#5010272)
It's absolutely the case that participating users add more to the system than nonparticipating users (hmm, possibly moderated a bit by signal-to-noise ratio...?)
Re:Why You Should Join Diaspora Now, Like Your Freedom Depen...
by Tloewald on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:51AM
(#5007369)
It seems like the only way to fight Facebook would be to embrace (er wait, leverage) it ... Something that simply crossposts to your account but draws anyone interested out. Whether the tool is like FB or G+ or Twitter or something else is irrelevant, it needs to integrate with all of the above while holding YOUR stuff outside.
No, you miss the point. The purpose of social network is connecting people. Posting a picture for mom to see it is just one example of social interactions, there are multiple others which can be done through social network. For example exchanging ideas. Yes, Diaspora needs to add more features to become more friendly and versatile. But it's not about making a Facebook clone. It's about giving people an option of free social network. The point of the article - start using it now if you care about freedom. The more users it will get, the more feedback and more potential developers. It's not yet about "those who post pictures just come now - it'll replace all your Facebook use cases".
If Diaspora can't show a reasonable path to get a critical mass of users, then it's not worth to invest time and emotions in posting there.
I'd say if one doesn't share the sentiment of the author of that article (i.e. understanding of the need for free social networks), then one won't find reasons to invest time and effort in it already now. But the article isn't addressed to such people on the other hand.