News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by paimapi on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:43PM (#50064105)
> Why would you assume disciplines outside those in majority representation here aren’t equally, or even more, detailed?

Because there's literally a market carve-out for city-driving electric cars like the Leaf and the BMW i-series. As much as I would love for a group of engineers to go hard on specs out of passion, I also believe that corporations are run much more by MBA-brained types than engineers now and any over-engineering outside of strict business criteria will be immediately vetoed and dumped

> My first car was a used 1998 Renault Clio

And these days the over-reliance on plastics for structure and cost reduction in combination with large scale production sourcing issues that are hangovers from a global pandemic and an increasingly aggressive imperial trade regime by certain bad actors means there's little chance you are getting similar quality standards like those from 20+ years ago

Enshittification is a real thing and I'm not the kind of corporate brand loyalist who still believes these companies are going out of their way to make a car better than it needs to be

Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by jacquesm on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:18PM (#50064898)
I've had 700 kg cars that rivalled sports cars for grip and ability to accelerate. To say that sub 1 ton cars are going to be unpleasant to drive at highway speeds is a statement that does not jive with my 43 years of driving experience on three continents and in many types of vehicle and road conditions.

What is far more important than total mass is mass distribution, width of the tires (which can be an advantage and a disadvantage depending on the conditions) and traction model. Noise is a function of isolation and shape of the body and road contact and here lighter cars have the advantage: substantially reduced tire noise.

Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by paimapi on Monday October 12, 2026 @08:37PM (#50065050)
I don't think it's impossible to have a small car that drives great - I drove a CR-X as a starter car and upgraded to a 00's Celica. I think the likelihood of a sub-1-tonne EV being specced outside of it's intended market niche at this price point in this stage of corporate wealth hoarding is extremely low. If it does turn up that the car is well-suited for highway driving, I'm happy to eat crow but that doesn't mean that I won't still think the probability of the inverse is higher until that point.
Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by jacquesm on Monday October 12, 2026 @09:35PM (#50065470)
There are plenty of small cars that drive great. In fact some of the best driving cars are the smaller ones. But you have your mind made up in spite of lots of evidence so I think that maybe there are other reasons or other definitions that make 'driving great' land in a different set of qualities than most people would associate with 'driving'. I normally associate that with handling, ability to accelerate/decelerate and in general that the car does what I want it to. Heavier cars have a very clear disadvantage here.

But if, for instance, you're hauling lumber then most small cars are not going be driving great. Ditto if you have to move a family of five (or more). So without your definition of what 'well suited for highway driving' is specified in terms that I can appreciate that do not include the actual driving characteristics of the car then it is very hard to have a productive conversation, regardless of 'corporate wealth hoarding' or other off-topic bits. FWIW I've had just about every type of Citroen and without exception they handled very well within their respective weight class, and they also held their own in terms of hauling capacity. Reliability, now that is something where we can probably come into agreement, the French car industry for the longest time had serious issues (but not as many as their UK counterparts). Even so that too is a thing that is mostly in the past.

Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by NoLinkToMe on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:08AM (#50068319)
I mean a Toyota Yaris (first facelift) from 2016 for example sits around a ton (1070), and it's completely comfortable to drive on the highway.

And it's not some niche car, it's one of the most sold compact cars on the planet. And the 2026 versions are actually slightly lighter at 1025 and are very comfortable.

Of course comfort is up to interpretation, and as cars get better, our window of expectation moves, the cars my dad used to drive for 8 hours in a row for our summer vacations in the 1970s are considered ridiculously loud and cramped by today's standards. Just like Kings of the past had no tropical fruit in winter, while even unknown shitty corps hand them out for free to their unpaid interns at this point, our standards move.

But even with today's standards I think a modern Yaris at 1 ton (+2%) is completely fine for highway driving.

Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by Lio on Monday October 12, 2026 @07:45PM (#50064615)
> like the Leaf and the BMW i-series.

I don't know about the i-series but the current Leaf is not a city car. Nissan's small city car is the Pixa.

The Leaf is mid sized and well designed for longer distance travel with a range of 387 miles.

Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by yourusername on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @04:31AM (#50068490)
The current i5 is a 2.3 ton car with 600 horsepower. A city car.
Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by wazoox on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @09:25AM (#50071362)
A big city car. Interpret as you wish :)
Re:Citroen revives the 2CV for an electric age by bartread on Monday October 12, 2026 @06:58PM (#50064235)
> Because there's literally a market carve-out for city-driving electric cars like the Leaf and the BMW i-series.

And? Do you think these cars are incapable of highway driving? What do you think happens when manufacturers release cars that are terribly noisy in the cabin at highway speeds?

I’ll tell you: what’s always happened. Reviewevers and consumers will slag them off and people will vote with their wallets.

A lightweight car is not a car that inherently has to be unpleasant to drive at speed.

And you think cost cutting is new? Robert McNamara and his “whizz kids” near ruined the reputation of the Ford Motor Company due to quality issues stemming from his relentless cost cutting in the 1950s and 1960s. What he and, really, what the rest of Detroit were doing enabled the success of Japanese manufacturers in the USA because they made a higher quality product and charged less for it.

> And these days the over-reliance on plastics for structure and cost reduction

People have been complaining about this since the 1980s. Plastics have been used extensively in cars for decades, including in ways that compromise the durability of critical components and sensors. This is not a new problem.

It is sheer ignorance to claim that any car weighing less than a ton will inherently be unpleasant to drive at highway speeds.