News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: PS2 games statically recompiled to WebAssembly by fwip on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:11AM (#50056739)
I think it's less that recompilation is stealing the code, and more that it is a piece of the puzzle to 'stealing' the game experience (the thing that you would pay for).

Emulators + ROM is one way to do that. Recompiling from the ROM is another. I think that for most people, your stance on if emulating is stealing or piracy, will well-predict how you feel about recompilation tools.

Re:Show HN: PS2 games statically recompiled to WebAssembly by ndriscoll on Monday October 12, 2026 @12:14PM (#50058546)
In what world would emulation (i.e. product compatibility) be stealing or piracy? In a functioning market, we would have e.g. a Steambox advertising fully supported PS5 compatibility (and PS4 and PS3 and PS2 and PS1 and Wii and Gamecube and N64 etc. etc.), or a Legion Go advertising Switch compatibility. We should all want competition. You shouldn't need to purchase an overpriced crappy handheld to play specific titles when a better, cheaper one could do it just as well.

I swear gamers have the most insane Stockholm syndrome. It's super common to see them say that it's a problem that there aren't enough "exclusives" for a console. Like, dude, the problem is that the console sucks next to its competition. You shouldn't want product tying to try to make you buy it.

Re:Show HN: PS2 games statically recompiled to WebAssembly by fwip on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @02:04PM (#50075973)
Emulation is primarily used for piracy. Easily 90% of emulator users are using ROMs that they do not have the rights to.
Re:Show HN: PS2 games statically recompiled to WebAssembly by ndriscoll on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @02:39PM (#50076524)
Possibly, but that's kind of a trivial observation when the only company selling ROMs is Sega, and everything else outside of PS1/PS2 requires a lot of technical sophistication to use original discs, by design of the companies complaining of piracy. Gen1 iPods were probably used for 90% or more pirated material too, but that's because the music industry really didn't want to sell music files (and went so far as to include malware on audio CDs to attempt to prevent legal copies). The iPod itself was still obviously legal.

You can also buy third party products that take original cartridges, but again the companies aren't interested in selling cartridges, so no surprise if they end up pirated.

It's like the Sega case: "we made it impossible to use our hardware without violating our trademark, and then they violated our trademark. OMG!" Okay? Don't do that.

Re:Show HN: PS2 games statically recompiled to WebAssembly by scheeseman486 on Monday October 12, 2026 @10:02PM (#50065657)
Emulators and ROMs are so normalized at this point that even Apple are implicitly OK with it.