News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A New Look for Facebook by jmduke on Thursday January 03, 2013 @05:30PM (#5005131)
My friends aren't overwhelmingly ugly, but they certainly don't take production-quality pictures. Judging a social app's beauty by the stock photos is like judging the fit of a shirt by how it looks on the model.
Re:A New Look for Facebook by catshirt on Thursday January 03, 2013 @06:07PM (#5005273)
this is not a fair analogy. if a model chooses to wear a shirt that fit poorly, then you are allowed to question the model's ability to dress themselves.

likewise, if Facebook chooses to saturate their pages with images they know are generally poorly shot, you are allowed to question Facebook's ability to dress itself.

Re:A New Look for Facebook by cookiecaper on Thursday January 03, 2013 @06:19PM (#5005328)
but facebook doesn't choose what photos get uploaded. They simply provide the platform for it and the content is up to the users. Most users take photos with camera phones, not DSLRs.
Re:A New Look for Facebook by anthemcg on Thursday January 03, 2013 @06:54PM (#5005475)
But to be fair, when you present your designs for the consideration of stock holders ( which this probably is) its important to make it look its best and since Facebook users technically can upload awesome DSLR style photos and it makes the design look far better, I forgive him and understand that this kind of presentation is more nessesary than really representing what it will look like.
Re:A New Look for Facebook by catshirt on Friday January 04, 2013 @12:40AM (#5006433)
your argument is fallacious in that i never made the assertion that Facebook chose what photos got uploaded. my point is exactly the opposite of that. (but i reserve some responsibility here- see my other response which clarifies a fallacy in my own argument).

a. Facebook does not get to choose what photos get uploaded

b. Facebook knows the overwhelming majority of these photos are of poor quality

as such, it would be short sighted for Facebook to incorporate a design which relied so heavily on shitty user generated photos.

Re:A New Look for Facebook by acchow on Friday January 04, 2013 @05:49AM (#5007090)
I'm not sure what point you're trying to make. Most comments above your's point out that the linked design prototype looks attractive mostly due to the high quality images. If implemented as the actual Facebook design, much of the appeal would be lost. That is, the prototype did not take "shit user generated photos" into designs at all. Facebook on the other hand, does.
Re:A New Look for Facebook by TeMPOraL on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:25AM (#5007318)
> as such, it would be short sighted for Facebook to incorporate a design which relied so heavily on shitty user generated photos.

The point is, the new layout discussed here relies in some way on the pictures being not shitty. The discussion here is about a layout for content that is not under Facebook's control.

Re:A New Look for Facebook by balloot on Friday January 04, 2013 @12:21AM (#5006384)
uh....You do realize that almost every photo on FB is user-generated, right?
Re:A New Look for Facebook by catshirt on Friday January 04, 2013 @12:37AM (#5006423)
your confusion may stem from the fact that i mistook the original analogy. they were calling the shirt into question. my response was calling the model into question. my mistake should be clear if you read both posts carefully. i will elaborate just in case.

every photo on Facebook is user generated. an overwhelming majority of them are bad photos. Facebook is completely aware of this.

as such, it would be an irresponsible design choice for Facebook to create such a huge presence for those photos, like the design proposal does. likewise, it is irresponsible of the proposal author to only use high resolution stock photos of decent looking people for their design.

perhaps my original post was not crystal clear. in retrospect i maintain that it was a fine explanation, albeit terse- and out of context given my misinterpretation. regardless of my post's clarity, your response makes you sound like a dick.

Re:A New Look for Facebook by Terretta on Friday January 04, 2013 @10:37AM (#5008028)
You've descended to name calling, taking offense over people not realizing your "mistake should be clear".

I respectfully submit that had what you meant to say been so clear, or had you followed your own advice to "read both posts carefully", perhaps you wouldn't have made the mistake twice.

Re:A New Look for Facebook by catshirt on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @01:24AM (#5030482)
not offended by any realization or lack thereof. i conceded; my point was entirely backwards given my misinterpretation. but the parent reply didn't warrant an apologetic tone. snark begets snark. i don't think "your tone sounds dickish" is name calling. but you're right, uncalled for nonetheless.