News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every NFL play for the past 10 years in CSV format by aidenn0 on Thursday January 03, 2013 @12:14PM (#5003327)
IANAL, but I asked one about this while ago; let's see if I can remember: It's complicated. The NFL broadcasts are copyrighted, and come with a statement that (among other things) distributing descriptions of the game is not allowed. That could be considered a derivative work.

On the other hand, a live performance is generally not protected from copyright, so if you attend a live game to collect the data, you may be in the clear.

The data isn't owned by the NFL, but all recordings of the games are, and so any data obtained by watching recordings of the games could potentially be controlled by the NFL.

Re:Every NFL play for the past 10 years in CSV format by _delirium on Thursday January 03, 2013 @12:32PM (#5003422)
It might not even violate the NFL's copyright if extracted from tapes. For one thing, something is only a "derived work" for copyright purposes if it's a "creative work" subject to copyright at all, and in the U.S., data sets comprising factual information aren't typically considered "creative". For another, it's not clear whether data about a recording is derived from the recording for copyright purposes. For example, a re-edit or mash-up of a film is clearly a derived work, but is a count of how many minutes each character speaks a derived work? Or is a Spotify-style algorithmic analysis of a song's musical style a derived work of the song?

I wouldn't want to put a large bet on where exactly those lines are drawn, though.

Re:Every NFL play for the past 10 years in CSV format by sethist on Thursday January 03, 2013 @12:18PM (#5003357)
IANAL too, but the NFL lost a relatively recent court case regarding fantasy football that, as far as I am aware, made the leagues statistics public knowledge as long as you compile the information yourself. Therefore the main legal issue with this data would be the source.