News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by harpersealtako on Friday October 09, 2026 @08:52AM (#50019777)
Then they presumably are fine with open weights models made by hobbyists by scraping publicly available art on boorus and such, yes? because they are neither made by corporations nor are they selling any product.

(to be clear, I don't think this is an accurate description of how artists feel about e.g. publicly released diffusion models. The core is not that it's made by "corporations" or the for-profit aspect or even the copyright infringement part, it's simply the understandable and not-at-all-unique-to-artists resentment at having your job or passion automated or displaced)

Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by asddubs on Friday October 09, 2026 @09:51AM (#50020558)
I think the reason artists wouldn't like hobbyists doing it either is just that they've been soured on it by corporations. Artists didn't reject AI in its infancy, or things like deepdream. But AI as it stands very clearly is exploitative, and what's more, it's flooded spaces formerly for human art with low quality generic garbage. Having those experiences bleeds over into your feelings about things that don't match the exact definition of the reason you're upset to begin with.
Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by cryptonym on Friday October 09, 2026 @09:27AM (#50020232)
True. they were fine providing advances to their field for others to learn and build from that shared legacy. They didn't agree for their work to be the base of auto-slopping at industrial scale. Quite easy to understand, except for AI-bros.
Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by wredcoll on Friday October 09, 2026 @09:43AM (#50020440)
How is this morally different from e.g. weavers and loom operators being automated or ceramics or anything else? Or programmers?

We've been automating people "out of jobs" since at least the start of the industrial revolution. It's generally considered to be a goos thing.

We had a sort of weird special case for copyright preventing certain types of machine automation and I've heard plenty of complaints about how that worked, but it more or less did work for a while.

Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by officeplant on Friday October 09, 2026 @02:30PM (#50024790)
>We've been automating people "out of jobs" since at least the start of the industrial revolution. It's generally considered to be a goos thing.

By who? The corporate bag holders?

Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by cryptonym on Monday October 12, 2026 @05:16AM (#50053590)
If ceramic industrialization relies massively on ceramic artist designs used with no authorization nor retribution, it may have been morally similar.

I don't know the details of ceramic industrialization.

Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by harpersealtako on Friday October 09, 2026 @10:20AM (#50020930)
I feel like "don't agree" is a weird framing, because it assumes that all technological innovations must have the explicit and affirmative consent of all parties they could directly or indirectly affect. Not to mention that "artists" are not a monolith any more than "AI bros" are.

I could sort of get behind something like this in theory (weighing each new technology based on whether it furthers the values of the community, and rejecting it if it doesn't, kinda like what the Amish do), but I'm not sure it's being applied neutrally or consistently here, nor do I think it works in practice especially for something as decentralized as a diffusion model, which are surprisingly simple to build and train and can run on a home GPU.

Re:I hired an illustrator to draw my house. Now it's my Home... by officeplant on Friday October 09, 2026 @02:29PM (#50024770)
>Then they presumably are fine with open weights models made by hobbyists by scraping publicly available art on boorus and such, yes? because they are neither made by corporations nor are they selling any product.

Why would anyone be fine with people explicitly not actually making art.

Scrapping and generating isn't art and isn't comparable to people tracing/copying/learning from existing art.