I'm the same way myself. I will say that even with multiple monitors "Metro" (modern) apps don't really perform well.
For whatever reason many of them aren't very information dense. So even if you move each one onto its own monitor for whatever reason much of the available space is wasted with solid colour or nonsense.
Take a look at this for example: http://i.imgur.com/TMSwc.png
Note how little of that is actual information and conversely how much of it is solid green background.
I'm all for having a multiple window UI accessible, or getting a rapid overview. But I find myself much preferring to unclutter my workspaces and have a single focus most of the time, and resort to the overview only rarely, especially because switching is so easy - I don't have to move big physical objects around in a stack, I can rapidly flick through a bunch of open windows on a carousel or get a display with a zoomed out overview.
I do find it important to be able to line up multiple windows though. Every now and again a single task will demand more than one window. I think that's where a lot of the disconnect comes from: Multiple windows on screen at once representing multiple tasks is a recipe for mental clutter. Multiple windows on screen that correspond precisely to a single, cohesive task is not.
"Imagine you were doing research and instead of spreading a number of books across your floor all open at the correct page you had them open stacked on top of each other and switched books when you needed to... Now tell me how frustrated you feel. Stuart Wakefield"
Although mostly single window, multiple screens kind of person myself I know the frustration of having to argue over the correct way for me to do my work that my paycheck depends on..