News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ADHD as a circadian rhythm disorder: evidence and implica... by hatthew on Thursday October 08, 2026 @08:35PM (#50014462)
How much do you think ADHD is a specific mental condition that one either has or doesn't have, versus a set of common symptoms that can have many causes? I wonder which direction a causal relationship between sleep and ADHD might be.
Re:ADHD as a circadian rhythm disorder: evidence and implica... by fc417fc802 on Friday October 09, 2026 @03:12AM (#50017112)
Pretty much anything we don't have a detailed mechanistic understanding of falls into the latter category - an arbitrary bag of sometimes unrelated symptoms, ie a fundamentally statistical categorization - regardless of what anyone might try to claim. This applies to everything across the natural sciences and medicine. If we can't model it in minute detail then we do not truly understand it and anyone attempting to claim otherwise is full of shit regardless of whatever credentials they might have somehow managed to stumble into holding.
Re:ADHD as a circadian rhythm disorder: evidence and implica... by TeMPOraL on Friday October 09, 2026 @04:20AM (#50017591)
Exactly this. Particularly in mental health, where verifying a mechanistic explanation is hard (at least doing so ethically is), many of the well-known problems are defined as clusters of highly correlated symptoms, because that's the best we can do at this point - but this is useful.

Not all highly correlated symptoms will turn out to have a common mechanistically-explainable cause, but all symptoms of a mechanistically-explainable cause obviously are highly correlated.

Re:ADHD as a circadian rhythm disorder: evidence and implica... by alterom on Friday October 09, 2026 @07:20PM (#50027803)
>How much do you think ADHD is a specific mental condition that one either has or doesn't have, versus a set of common symptoms that can have many causes?

The sign has been pretty specific that it's the first (specific condition), and not the latter.

To get the big thing out of the way: brain scans of people with ADHD show measurable differences in brain structure, activity, and neurotransmitter levels compared with neurotypical brains[1].

Secondly, ADHD is highly hereditary, to the tune of 75%+ chance[2].

But you don't need a brain scan for your answer. There's a reason ADHD is a thing in DSM (if it were merely "a set of common symptoms", it wouldn't be).

Each "symptom" (a manifestation of an ADHD trait) in and of itself may not be rare, and people in general may experience it during certain conditions.

ADHD is experiencing a hella lot of them off the list, for absolute majority of the time, all your life.

Please really, really pay attention to the example I gave. It looks like you glossed over it entirely.

And yes, I'm fully aware of the irony of asking someone to pay more attention in this thread.

> I wonder which direction a causal relationship between sleep and ADHD might be.

The ADHD --> horrible sleep causation is well established.

The horrible sleep --> ADHD symptoms become worse causation is also well established.

Horrible sleep --> ADHD causation is nonexistent. There is nothing indicating that ADHD could be an acquired condition. There's all the evidence to the contrary (you are born this way, as the song goes).

The study establishes that "fixing" circadian rhythm helps with ADHD symptoms, which is a Captain Obvious moment (full night's sleep makes brain work better, and we have difficulty getting it ever).

I'm not sure what other causation you are looking for.

[1] https://www.adhdevidence.org/blog/finding-order-in-the-compl...

[2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6477889/

Re:ADHD as a circadian rhythm disorder: evidence and implica... by hatthew on Friday October 09, 2026 @10:03PM (#50028786)
That makes sense, thanks. I think that matches my prior understanding, but recently people seem to talk a lot about "acquiring" ADHD, often from doomscrolling tiktok or something like that, and I wasn't sure about how much of that is true. Based on what you're saying, it sounds like the ADHD a lot of people claim they have is about as real as the OCD they also claim to have (i.e. minor symptoms that vaguely match), and the real thing is much more life-altering and deserves to not be diluted.