News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by jMyles on Thursday October 08, 2026 @04:33PM (#50011801)
That's the opposite of what my gut is telling me.

Hashes are so simple. There's no place for these crazy math attacks, which rely on rethinking long-standing and otherwise reasonable assumptions, to hide.

Surely we can all agree that there's no way to reverse a modulus.

Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by tptacek on Thursday October 08, 2026 @05:12PM (#50012384)
I think I agree with you in spirit but I don't think "there's no way to reverse a modulus" is the right way to say this. Like that's in a sense what Coppersmith does? (Several attacks on RSA can be thought of as in some way "reversing a modulus").
Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by jMyles on Thursday October 08, 2026 @05:26PM (#50012547)
> I think I agree with you in spirit

holy heck, the planets have aligned, HN

;-)

Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by tptacek on Thursday October 08, 2026 @05:48PM (#50012855)
We both work in security, right? That shouldn't surprise you so much.
Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by jMyles on Thursday October 08, 2026 @07:26PM (#50013868)
Actually man, I've transitioned pretty much full-time to playing bluegrass. Given that my life has been spend watching and helping the internet grow, most of my songs are about what it has felt like to live amidst that: https://justinholmes.bandcamp.com/

I still hack every day (current project: pickipedia.xyz), but I'm not doing security anymore except for my own projects.

And yes, I was more making light of what seem to me to largely be political disagreements; of course I respect your work at the same time.

It seems clearer and clearer to me that nationa-states cannot possibly withstand the evolution of the internet in any dignified way, and I pray for peaceful, simple deprecation of them. It seems to me to be the sensible stance, both in terms of security and in terms of joy.

My repeated sense - right honed or wrongly - is that you defend these structures (nation-states generally, and intelligence operations / state secret brokers in particular) in ways that I find hard to reconcile, even upon extended reflection.

Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by tptacek on Friday October 09, 2026 @10:23AM (#50020975)
Uh, ok, I was just saying my security takes are pretty normie and easy to agree with.
Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by dist-epoch on Thursday October 08, 2026 @04:54PM (#50012114)
Isn't it more secure mostly because of the mixing than the modulus.
Re:Vitalik Buterin backs crypto ‘bunker mode’ amid rapid AI ... by notnullorvoid on Thursday October 08, 2026 @09:36PM (#50014921)
The risk isn't about reversing the hash, it's about finding a hash collision. If the hash is the only reference to your public key on chain, one does not need to reverse the hash, they just need produce a key pair who's public hash collides.

Currently that's a large brute force problem. But my gut is telling me is that finding a forward pass method of restraining private key generation such that we know what kind of public key hash to expect at the end, should be easier than cracking elliptic curves.

I guess depending on your outlook some might view that as "reversing" a hash, but it's not like you are getting the original input which is a impossible problem (unless there is a bunch of info you already know about the input).