News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mathocalypse by dist-epoch on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @07:10PM (#50000001)
Arguably no human understands 100% of how a smartphone is produced, and, it doesn't matter?

Maybe no human will fully understand a future proof, but they could fully understand a little piece of it. And many humans in aggregate could understand it, each with their own little piece.

Re:The Mathocalypse by Tanjreeve on Thursday October 08, 2026 @03:01AM (#50002621)
The point isn't that 1 person can understand an entire smartphone silicon up. It's that 100% of a smartphone can be understood by people. A maths theorem that can only be partially understood/proven only has value as marketing collateral.
Re:The Mathocalypse by mrob on Thursday October 08, 2026 @04:20AM (#50003182)
>A maths theorem that can only be partially understood/proven only has value as marketing collateral.

There are many problems that aren't "interesting" in a mathematical sense but can still have valuable proofs. The entire field of formal methods in software development is mostly about this kind of problem. If I want to be sure that no input can cause out-of-bounds memory access, or that my superoptimizer found the lowest possible cycle count, I don't care if it's elegant, I just need some machine-readable proof I can run through my trusted verifier.

Re:The Mathocalypse by Tanjreeve on Thursday October 08, 2026 @01:03PM (#50008496)
When we use verification to build software. We have an actual software as an output and hopefully some sort of problem solvsd the verification is also not in an of itself valuable.
Re:The Mathocalypse by mrob on Thursday October 08, 2026 @01:25PM (#50008845)
The verification itself is valuable because it gives us confidence that the software is correct. This knowledge changes what we do with the software. E.g. do we need to sandbox it before processing untrusted inputs? Is it safe to put it on a hostile network? Can we use it to control an airplane or a nuclear reactor? Even if the code remains identical, formally verifying software improves it because it lets us use it in situations where unverified software would be too risky.
Re:The Mathocalypse by jcelerier on Thursday October 08, 2026 @08:24AM (#50004977)
For one person that understands a proof of some matrix multiplication algorithm lowering its current complexity bound in an useful way (e.g. not with absurdly gigantic <= 2nd order polynomial term), there's likely thousands of companies willing to pay for the improved efficiency
Re:The Mathocalypse by Tanjreeve on Thursday October 08, 2026 @01:00PM (#50008434)
And if anything that useful does come out of this output/"slop dump" then that might begin to make a strong argument for it. But every other time it was "that's the theorem done for the headline figuring out everything important and how to use it is an exercise for the reader".
Re:The Mathocalypse by losvedir on Thursday October 08, 2026 @12:01PM (#50007496)
> A maths theorem that can only be partially understood/proven only has value as marketing collateral.

If this is true, then what's really the point of math? A lot of math is actually useful. A proof regarding cryptography, for example, would have practical application even if not understandable by humans.

Re:The Mathocalypse by Tanjreeve on Thursday October 08, 2026 @12:55PM (#50008361)
Cryptography is 100% understandable by humans so I'm not sure what the point is. You do understand that the argument isn't everything has to be understandable by every human right just to check?
Re:The Mathocalypse by ben_w on Thursday October 08, 2026 @07:35AM (#50004592)
While any logical proof written in lean can be broken down into things a human can follow, there is no requirement that the whole proof of something is ever simple enough that all humans combined could follow it.

Given the LLMs are struggling to explain themselves clearly, but also that these explanations cleared up somewhat by having an expert using one to query some of this research, but also the LLMs can solve problems faster than humans can read the proofs, it is possible for this category to have both examples of things that can be rendered in a human-comprehensible form, and also examples where it is not.

As an analogy: any human can check any single arithmetical calculation from a computer, that's not even particularly difficult. But a Raspberry Pi Zero can do those arithmetical calculations so fast that even if literally every single human was trained to do this at the level of the current world record holder, humanity as a whole could not keep up.