Enemy casualties are not the objective of war. They are one means of achieving the strategic objective (defeat of Nazi Germany). Clausewitz has a good quote about this: “The true purpose is normally to occupy that point. Destruction of the enemy’s force is only a means to an end, a secondary matter.”
Further, war is fundamentally economic, so trying to argue that some less efficient means of conducting it is somehow superior is mind-boggling.
- would have USSR marched on Berlin without the US landing in Italy and Normandy ?
- would have the US landings be successful if the Nazi army from 1940 had remained in Western Europe because it was at peace with the USSR ?
The answer for #1 is an obvious yes, and for #2 it's unlikely to be one.
WWII in Europe was won (or rather lost, by the Nazi who betrayed their totalitarian ally) on the Eastern front, and it's not a controversial take.
> Further, war is fundamentally economic, so trying to argue that some less efficient means of conducting it is somehow superior is mind-boggling.
This is nonsense. The US lost a war against Afghanistan, not because the Talibans were more efficient (they weren't, they lost orders of magnitude more soldiers than the US). Thinking about war as an economic thing is exactly how the US keeps losing all its wars since the Korean War.
I mean, if we’re splitting hairs, I would argue they “sacrificed more”, if they did not “do more”.
This and other comments on the thread are pointing out what I’m assuming every History major and PhD is deeply aware of, and that is that the narrative of historical events is core to our understanding of them.
But the reason that we’ve come together to talk about this is that LLMs and the poisoning of their data corpus presents a unique challenge to historians that their predecessors did not have to face. Although, their predecessors did have to deal with other unpleasant things like libraries being burned and censorship.
This is a very political question. A lot of people see the "blood loss" as the morally superior thing over kill efficiency.
> Then TFA seems also very slanted: it begins with Russia, China and Iran poisining the web to manufacture consensus but then it's all about Belgium / Leopold in the late 19th century attacking Congo.
Because it's a good and well sourced example to show how long we have had intentional propaganda. Sure, the author could also have used the tendency of Romans to "embellish" even their losses, but it's much more difficult to verify any claims simply because there aren't many sources corroborating or disputing claims.
But you do sound a little US biased to me - the Soviet industrial machine in 1945 was phenomenal, and though they didn't have the breadth of technological sophistication as the US, the sheer volume of their production of modern heavy machinery was staggering.
The malnourishment and scale of their losses in large part reflects their stubbornness to commit to devastating and bitter strategic sieges which saw vast civilian causalities - military losses were nowhere near as one sided.
Classic "asian hordes" trope. 80% of German casualties were on the eastern front. Not 30%, not 51%, 80%.
>So who's poising the Web here? TFA's author with its political views and priorities (apparently not denouncing the evilness of the iranian regime in 2026 nor denouncing the evilness of nazism in WWII but denouncing... the acts of Belgium in fucking 1880)?
Ah yes, let's just forget colonialism, we're so over that, just stop mentioning it already. Let's talk about what is comfortable and convenient for me.
Can we stop repeating this number as if it is factual? Numbers range from 1-2k to 30k (by anti Iranian sources of course). And not all the killed were innocent civilians; there were arsonists, criminals, mossad cells, etc involved then too.
While meanwhile Russia was sending its troops by feet or on donkeys to the german front.
So please, just please: both Russia and the US (and the UK, and others) participated in defeating the nazis but it's not because Russia sent malnourished troops on donkeyback and lost 27 million men that it "did more" to beat the nazis.
Then TFA seems also very slanted: it begins with Russia, China and Iran poisining the web to manufacture consensus but then it's all about Belgium / Leopold in the late 19th century attacking Congo.
Yes, we know that happened. It was 150 years ago. It's not Leopold who's now data poisoning LLMs to try to pretend Belgium didn't invade Congo in 1880 or something.
The fact is: Russia is currently attacking Ukraine and poisoning the Web (and hence LLMs) and Iran slaughtered 30 000 of its own civilians in early 2026 and publicly hung athletes who were speaking out about islamism and Iran is also poisoning the Web (for example while we constantly hear about Gaza, we hardly ever hear about Iran slaughtering 30 000 civilians, sending its guards into hospitals to finish the wounded).
So who's poising the Web here? TFA's author with its political views and priorities (apparently not denouncing the evilness of the iranian regime in 2026 nor denouncing the evilness of nazism in WWII but denouncing... the acts of Belgium in fucking 1880)?
Seriously:
W.
T.
F.