News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by enraged_camel on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @02:57PM (#4998861)
At the risk of sounding too harsh, I'll admit that I was expecting some kind of groundbreaking insight on improving my life. Instead, all I got was the same generic "exercise" and "laugh more" bullshit. Gosh, perhaps I should just tickle myself!

At the abstract level, I find it a bit depressing that the blogosphere seems to be chock full of people who regurgitate common knowledge and attempt to present it as something new. There seems to be very few people who have unique insights worth following and sharing.

My rule with my personal blog has always been: don't write it if it is not new, original, or at least somewhat interesting. This is perhaps why I stopped doing it. :P

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by maneesh on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:02PM (#4998895)
Do you exercise daily? Do you take walks in nature? Do you keep a gratitude journal? Do you meditate?

Because if there is a single one of these that you don't do, maybe the problem is that you don't execute on the good advice already around you.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by 27182818284 on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @04:46PM (#4999506)
No, I think what the parent is expressing is the same thing that happens when someone gets the flu. They often say "Get rest and drink plenty of fluids." and my thoughts were always "Really? I was going to go dehydrate myself and lift weights. Thank goodness I ran into you..."

It is so common at this point, I"m not sure it needs repeated by yet another blog. I can kinda see the parent's point in that regard.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by diminoten on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @05:43PM (#4999787)
Am I the only one who almost literally vomits when I hear the phrase, "gratitude journal"?

Maybe it is just me, and I'm some kind of happiness hating troll (I really don't think so, though!) but there's a certain point at which I feel like a person keeping gratitude journal is trying to stave off a deeper and more problematic depression that ought to honestly be addressed with more serious activities besides writing down what you're grateful for every day.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by mongol on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @06:15PM (#4999954)
I never heard of the concept until a few moments ago and I already know that I don't like it.

EDIT: Now I reflected why I didn't like it. And it is the word gratitude. Granted, I am not a native English speaker but Wikipedia tells me this: "Gratitude, thankfulness, gratefulness, or appreciation is a feeling or attitude in acknowledgment of a benefit that one has received or will receive. " In other words, it implies that there is someone in the other end of a happy feeling to be feel thankful to. And sometimes there is, but being grateful for nice weather, hearing birds singing or being able to walk (not being disabled) implies to me that there is someone "larger" (read a God) out there to be grateful to. And that does not sit well with me. For example, I can be happy to be in good health, but that does not imply that gratitude goes with it.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by bostonpete on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @11:18PM (#5000999)
Meh. I'm not religious but I feel grateful and thankful for precious time I get to spend with my kids, for beautiful weather, etc. That doesn't mean I'm grateful to anyone or anything in particular.

Honestly, some people are so militantly anti-religion that they get up in arms (so to speak) at anything that could even be construed as having religious connotations.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by javert on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @07:30PM (#5000320)
Spot on analysis.

I think it would be interesting to have a gratitude journal in which gratitude to myself is copiously recorded. e.g. "I'm really grateful that I had the dedication to get up early this morning so that I could make this day more useful to myself."

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by codegeek on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:51PM (#4999203)
"same generic "exercise" and "laugh more""

Sure this is a no-shit sherlock kind of moment. But how many of us are actually doing the same generic "exercise" and "laugh more" and make conscious effort to do it well ? It is hard and always worth stressing.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by Cl4rity on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:24PM (#4999037)
I happen to like Eric Barker's work, so I'm going to defend it. Judging by your response, you just read the subheadings and not the supporting text that accompanied them. If you did, you'd see links to the research that supports these "generic" pieces of advice.

It's not enough to know that exercising and laughter will improve your health, but you need to know why--the stuff that Barker puts on his site or on Wired is research-based. It isn't just garbage from link bait sites like pickthebrain.com.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by enraged_camel on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:34PM (#4999092)
Why do I need to know why laughter improves my health? This is a serious question. Do people laugh because humor helps cope with stress, which leads to better immune systems, reduced risk of heart attack and stroke, less pain during dental work and a longer life? Or do they laugh because they find something funny? I would posit that there is not a single person who read that blog post and thought "gee, I should laugh more often because it has all these health benefits!"

Perhaps that's the problem with the post in general: it is not practical. For example, instead of (or in addition to) saying that exercise is good for you, it could say "here are some exercise programs for beginners" and post links to P90X or Couch-to-5K. That way, the post could become a useful resource for people who actually want to improve their life, rather than a regurgitation of commonly-known facts.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by gknoy on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:51PM (#4999200)
Having an explanation of why helps our bullshit detector, and lets us re-evaluate claims if the explanation's basis falters later. If someone says, "X is bad for you because of Y", that may sound plausible. If they say that "Study Z shows that X causes Y, so don't do X", it's VERY much more plausible.

More importantly, if study Z turns out to be a hoax, we can look at the claims that used that as their basis and re-evaluate them.

You make a pretty good point about ways to make the blog posts more useful, though.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by kscaldef on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @04:12PM (#4999338)

    Why do I need to know why laughter improves my health? 
Because otherwise someone else on HN will say: "citation needed!"
Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by Cl4rity on Friday January 04, 2013 @11:44AM (#5008399)
As another commenter says, it helps the bullshit detector. Why know why anything works? If we just follow advice blindly, it may do us no good.

Your line of questioning is all wrong. You said, "I would posit that there is not a single person who read that blog post and thought 'gee, I should laugh more often because it has all these health benefits!'"

Therein lies the flaw in your thinking. You don't read something like this and think you should laugh more just for the sake of laughing and its health benefits. Instead, you'd read something like that, understand WHY laughter has those benefits, and then make an effort to put yourself in situations where you'd be more relaxed and open to laughter, like hanging out with funny friends or taking a date to a comedy club.

In fact, you answered your own question: Why do we need to know why laughter improves health? Is it because laughter helps cope with stress?

BOOM. You answered your question.

Maybe that's one of the reasons, but if you dig deeper, maybe there are more. Then once you begin to understand how and why certain behaviors and situations affect our lives, you can adjust accordingly. Maybe you don't need to laugh all the time if you understand that laughter is primarily a coping or stress-reduction mechanism. Maybe you can go do other activities that have the same effects.

You need to think about this stuff differently.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by frogpelt on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @05:06PM (#4999609)
Welcome to the Internet!

It has increased the speed and frequency at which we share ideas, almost all of them unoriginal.

Ironically, you came to Hacker News to get ideas, which is in itself a giant arena for everyone to discover things that others have already discovered.

If you're looking for newness and originality, you should probably unplug.

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by enraged_camel on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @05:13PM (#4999637)
I come to HN mostly for the discussions. In fact in most cases I read the discussion first to decide whether the article posted is worth reading in the first place. So the purpose of my comment was to warn others who do the same not to waste their time. :)
Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by frogpelt on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @05:18PM (#4999662)
Well in that case, perhaps you are consuming a slightly larger helping of original thought.
Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by stephengillie on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:29PM (#4999066)
My rule with criticism is that if it doesn't work to improve the original, it's a waste of your time, my time, and the author's time. :p

What groundbreaking insights would you provide? It's somewhat obvious which points you'd remove; with what would you replace them?

Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by enraged_camel on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @03:35PM (#4999098)
See my response to Cl4rity.
Re:What should you do every day to improve your life? by stephengillie on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @07:17PM (#5000249)
Point taken, I'll stop wasting my time and your time.