News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by PorciiVorbesc on Saturday October 03, 2026 @04:14PM (#49947367)
Define "actual source"? In good faith.
Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by satvikpendem on Saturday October 03, 2026 @04:17PM (#49947390)
As in the study or survey or analytics segment where the data was collected to produce the report.
Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by PorciiVorbesc on Saturday October 03, 2026 @04:29PM (#49947485)
"The analytics", is the publicly available training dataset of the LLMs that share the same common opinion on that DE market share.

What do you expect exactly? Do you want me to now manually parse through terabytes of information at your whim for your own convenience? Sorry, but I'm not your personal unpaid servant.

If you wish to disprove me in the comment section, then you need to do the manual work and show us that the my quoted LLMs statistics are wrong. I'm not your personal errand boy to do your bidding, 'massa'.

Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by satvikpendem on Saturday October 03, 2026 @04:51PM (#49947651)
Point at the public dataset then if it's so public. You really have no idea how the LLM is parsing the data and could easily be hallucinating. That you find being called out on this as some sort of insult is quite telling and frankly funny, what a strong reaction to someone asking for a basic source when the burden of proof is on you to prove (or at least show a source that) these stats are right, not on anyone else to disprove AI bullshit.
Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by PorciiVorbesc on Saturday October 03, 2026 @05:13PM (#49947835)
Sorry, it's not my job to provide for you the things that you demand from me at your whims, because the original comment I replied to with LLM data also did not bring peer-reviewable information as proof that COSMIC is a TOP 5 DE, and yet you did not demand proof from them in that case. Why is that?

Did you just blindly trust the opinions of others on this topic, and yet I'm the one who has to provide peer-reviewable data for you to back-up mine? Sorry, I'm not your unpaid lackey. Try to formulate a better (counter)argument for why their baseless opinion is right, but my LLM backed up opinion is wrong, if you wish for a even-footed good-faith argument.

Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by satvikpendem on Saturday October 03, 2026 @06:05PM (#49948242)
I ask them for the same source (and looks like they provided it), your comment wasn't special. LLMs however are especially less trustworthy, that's why. It's not my job to educate you on why they are, as you say, and why people aren't trusting your comments.
Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by PorciiVorbesc on Saturday October 03, 2026 @06:28PM (#49948402)
>I ask them for the same source (and looks like they provided it)

I also saw it now. That blog is not a representative ground truth, but just another opinion piece, which I can respect as an opinion of the blog's user base, but I can't take as an accurate real world statistic, same how aggregate opinions you read on HN are not representative of the actual real world.

I hope you can understand my PoV. You can also disagree if you want, but you'll need to bring something more than "that's wrong because LLMs sometimes hallucinate" as proof that Gemini's data is wrong in this case.

Re:Pop!_OS bans AI-generated code from much of its codebase by satvikpendem on Saturday October 03, 2026 @06:55PM (#49948569)
In theory if you brought a better source than that person then I'd agree with you, but,

> you'll need to bring something more than "that's wrong because LLMs sometimes hallucinate" as proof that Gemini's data is wrong in this case.

actually I can say it's wrong or likely to be wrong especially if it doesn't cite the sources it uses. And if it does, then just paste the sources here instead of the LLM output. It is also unknown where it got the info and as someone else said, you ask it two different times and it gave two different answers, thus it is unreliable.