Re:<input type="password" maxlength="20"> prevents me from l...
by danaris on Saturday October 03, 2026 @02:24PM
(#49946532)
Except that
a) when humans generate passwords, they are not perfectly random; they are memorable, which means they often use dictionary words, which are vulnerable to dictionary attacks
b) even if they use moderately good passwords, that can't be broken with the dictionary, there's a high chance of password reuse, and many passwords have already been leaked
c) when password managers generate truly random passwords, they run into exactly the problem in the article
You are so focused on the math of the situation, you ignore the practical realities.
a) when humans generate passwords, they are not perfectly random; they are memorable, which means they often use dictionary words, which are vulnerable to dictionary attacks
b) even if they use moderately good passwords, that can't be broken with the dictionary, there's a high chance of password reuse, and many passwords have already been leaked
c) when password managers generate truly random passwords, they run into exactly the problem in the article
You are so focused on the math of the situation, you ignore the practical realities.