News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nazi Germany had no hope of making an atomic bomb, uraniu... by Lumich on Friday October 02, 2026 @05:06PM (#49938615)
« likely correct in the narrative » — What if it is built on flawed premises?

  I was keyed up for my first view of an atom-bombed city, prepared
  for the radically new sights suggested by the exciting descriptions
  I had read and heard. But to my utter astonishment, Hiroshima
  from the air looked exactly like all the other burned-out cities I
  had observed!
Alexander de Seversky, Air Power: Key to Survival, 1950

quoted in:

Michael Palmer, Hiroshima revisited, 2020–23

https://mpalmer.heresy.is/webnotes/HR/

Re:Nazi Germany had no hope of making an atomic bomb, uraniu... by ajnin on Saturday October 03, 2026 @07:40AM (#49943348)
That's the second puzzling comment you've posted on this subject. Are you suggesting atom bombs don't exist?
Re:Nazi Germany had no hope of making an atomic bomb, uraniu... by Lumich on Saturday October 03, 2026 @04:07PM (#49947311)
I've learnt that flat out statements aren't always the best way. I suggest curious minds consider the evidence laid out in Palmer's book, which is not only free but also a true pioneering work, to then “come to their own conclusions” (if they're into that kind of thing – not everyone is).

I had never really understood why in the early 90s “nuclear weapons” ceased to be “a problem” (a media talking point) moreless overnight “when the Wall came down”, as the arsenals still existed. A dozen years later I realized the Russians kept talking about them, and I was worried about “stability”.

And there were other things I couldn't make sense of – such as what does it mean for an aircraft to be “nuclear-capable”? I mean – there's a payload, and there's speed and altitude, and there may be safety concerns, but nothing really seems to fit when you look at what's considered “capable” and what's not.

And why did we have barrages to stop tank armies entering “from the East”?

And why spend so much on military in the first place when the bomb dwarfs everything? Why all this insanity?

Another dozen years later I found that same Swedish naval engineer whom Palmer would later also find in the exact same way, and whom he mentions in the preface. It was a bit like “tolle, lege” although of course I don't compare to Augustine.

And then the insanity started making sense again, but in a very different way.

But there's something else that strikes me profoundly when I read discussions such as these. It's not about the topic, it's about the participants. It's the way they talk about it – the way “the Bomb” has become an object of both erudition and veneration. “The Bomb” is studied and idolized, intellectually hugged and worshipped – while the victims are a mere projection screen for the greatness of “the Bomb”.

How can that be?

To me, the psychology of things is often the most interesting aspect. And I think what we have here is a cover story, a self-serving cover story, and that is not an accident.

Re:Nazi Germany had no hope of making an atomic bomb, uraniu... by ajnin on Saturday October 03, 2026 @08:55PM (#49949464)
A cover story for what ? We have eyewitnesses of Hiroshima. We have videos of atomic bomb tests. We have seismic recordings of underground blasts. Multiple countries claim to have independently developed the bomb. A coverup on a global scale, lasting for decades, implicating people from the military, scientists, everyday people from many countries, without a single person breaking secrecy. Why ?
Re:Nazi Germany had no hope of making an atomic bomb, uraniu... by Lumich on Sunday October 04, 2026 @10:51AM (#49954411)
I'd reply but it's pointless, all my comments are now stillborn, dead on arrival. It appears some people on HN, despite all the talk about “curiosity”, don't like seeing their topics of predilection and veneration challenged by views and evidence that could lead people to reconsider whether the establishment view is correct at all.
Re:Nazi Germany had no hope of making an atomic bomb, uraniu... by Lumich on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:35PM (#49971150)
So my sibling comment posted yesterday did not get killed, unlike 49953689, 49954141, as well as 49938615 and 49941900 before.

« A cover story for what ? » — To cover up dozens of heinous mass-murdering crimes with veneration of “the Bomb” ?

« We have eyewitnesses of Hiroshima. » — Yes, we do. You'll find some in the Palmer book (link in the dead comments). You'll also find some in chapter 19 of the Rhodes book (The Making of the Atomic Bomb), where they're more numerous but less interesting, as the book serves a different purpose: it's not an investigation, but a narrative. About 60 % of the eyewitnesses Rhodes quotes were children, and what we have is their recollection decades later. Let me quote this:

  A five-year-old girl: The whole city … was
  burning. Black smoke was billowing up and we
  could hear the sound of big things exploding.
Big things exploding? Sounds like multiple explosions. But the testimony, as quoted in Rhodes, is too brief to make much of it, and, like many others, not exactly precise, and hence not substantial. And also probably a much later recollection. And she was only five years old.

« We have videos of atomic bomb tests. » — Those are separate incidents.

« Multiple countries … Why ? » — You're rushing to ulterior questions, if not to conclusions. Palmer focuses on the Hiroshima and Nagasaki evidence. And there is more than enough in there already that is “puzzling”, to reuse your expression. So I'd prefer to stay focused.