Re:Gemini 4 Argon
by tobias2014 on Wednesday September 30, 2026 @06:34PM
(#49915347)
That is really the biggest beef I have with agy over others, the forced auto compaction at the 250k token threshold (3.8-flash), while the model itself (via API) would be fine with a 1M context window. Even if the model is great, restricting context to 250k tokens (and auto compacting no matter what) limits certain applications and workflows somewhat.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There is auto compaction at 250k? Having used agy for months with multi day sessions, I have never seen this.
Re:Gemini 4 Argon
by tobias2014 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:20PM
(#50080824)
I think up until a few versions ago, you wouldn't even know it happened because it didn't tell you. But you can always check with /context. For many applications the compaction is very good, so you likely never noticed.
Wtf. Can you turn that off? On CC I have compaction completely turned off. Iād rather hit the hard out of context limit at 1M.
I find this discussion interesting. I've had huge increases in accuracy and huge reductions in token usage by capping my Claude models at 200k instead of 1M. I find 1M unusable and wasteful and feel that 200k should be the default. This also makes sense given that the whole reason people use "Ralph loops" is to keep the context window small for all tasks to get better results. Of course, clearing it yourself and manually managing it is better, but if I have 8 projects going in different terminal tabs I'm not watching any one of them that closely to effectively do that.
What are people using 1M context window for?
Re:Gemini 4 Argon
by tobias2014 on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:26PM
(#50080859)
The problem for me is that it's a forced compaction at a fixed token number without wiggle room. I would rather run into e.g. 300k and be done than have a compaction at 250k, followed by a compressed context where it has to try and re-read what is needed. There are many times where I had to force it to re-read something in full because of its complexity, and which would get lost in compaction and not fully recovered afterwards.