News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by jrockway on Monday December 31, 2012 @04:42PM (#4991005)
This seems a little harsh to me. Everyone takes their phones to school. Everyone sends texts at school. The ship has sailed. If you're the one without the phone, you're the weirdo that nobody will talk to.

This mom should have gotten her son a leash instead. Then at least the power play would have been obvious to everyone.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by wib on Monday December 31, 2012 @04:51PM (#4991039)
"No porn."

Thanks mom!

I'm mortified for the kid.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by vy8vWJlco on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:42PM (#4991200)
Boy, am I glad my Mom didn't have a "no porn rule." I'd have been really confused about my body and people's behaviours. (I also would have been in a totally different field; turns out optimizing a 386 for fast porn teaches you everything you'll need for your career.) I might have even turned to religion.

Our society is set up in such a way that porn is one of the few "safe" ways for young people to figure their junk out. Heaven help us if they do censor the net.

He probably thought he'd get to play Angry Birds under his superman blanket. (Remember reading comics with a flashlight?) Instead he got an obligation and an emasculating letter. "Don't say anything you wouldn't say in public" probably would have sufficed. He can't even throw it under a bus for what it represents, because it isn't his. It's hers, and she's loaned it to him... :\

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by objclxt on Monday December 31, 2012 @07:41PM (#4991477)
>"porn is one of the few "safe" ways for young people to figure their junk out"

I disagree with this. By virtue of the market, most porn online is targeted towards men. The majority of pornography thus fulfils masculine desires, which is not necessarily what women want.

One Swedish study (abstract here[1], but you can find the stats I use cited elsewhere in full) of 4,000 high school students found that a much larger proportion of girls described pornography as "sexually off-putting" (it is worth noting that Sweden has an extremely progressive sex education policy in its schools). Pornography re-enforces masculine stereotypes - someone viewing pornography at a young age may take that to be 'how it is done', rather than illustrating a fantasy.

Now that doesn't mean there isn't healthy pornography: as other people have pointed out, there's something for everyone when it comes to porn online. But a 13 year old boy (or girl) looking for porn is almost certainly going to start at the lowest common denominator, and that's porn that's often denigrating to women at best.

Before I'm flamed into oblivion, I am not against pornography: I am merely suggesting that typical porn - the kind that you may run across as a teenager, on the more accessible sites - is not "one of the few 'safe' ways for young people to figure their junk out".

This is why I think if you are a parent it is important not to ban, or discourage, your children from watching pornography, but to make sure they understand that porn fundamentally is about fulfilling fantasies, and is not always an accurate portrayal of reality. Those first encountering porn may not necessarily be aware of that.

[1]: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140197110...

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by vy8vWJlco on Monday December 31, 2012 @09:19PM (#4991652)
Yup. Fantasy != reality. I actually think the Internet helped me learn that early.

By "safe" I mean safer than the alternatives (public indecency, teen pregnancy, unsafe or exploitive real-life situations, etc, etc), not categorically "best," or even necessarily useful for everyone. If girls are statistically put off by porn, that's OK. I want it to be OK to seek what feels right for me too, and I'm glad I was able to at a time when I was high on testosterone; the difference between a sex offender and a nice normal guy can sometimes just be whether or not a person has a "safe" outlet.

Video games provide stress relief and can be seen similarly (girls might not play the same types of video games, even though most FPS games are some of the most common), but as long as people can distinguish fantasy from reality, they can be healthy outlets. Self-moderation is also a learned skill.

I'm not trying to be prescriptive, I just hate to see a nifty tech "gift" become a point of shame (emasculation). As jlgreco said, it's biologically hardwired. IMHO, he's probably still going to look for porn, only now he may feel like it's "bad"... That he's bad. Prohibition is a land-mine of social and psychological problems. Just look at catholic priests.

I agree with your conclusion.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by jlgreco on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:59PM (#4991247)
I agree, though I think a "no porn" rule is just as likely to backfire on a parent by driving a child away from religion. When religion is just that thing that forbids doing things that you don't want to do anyway (murder, steal, build a cow out of gold in your backyard, etc) it is easy to never bother putting any thought into it one way or the other. But when you tell a teenage boy that his biologically hardwired desires are evil... there is a good chance that kid is going to start wondering what exactly the purpose of that rule is and how relevant it is to his own life.

It could go either way I think, but it is a very polarising thing to impose on a young adult.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by sp332 on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:51PM (#4991226)
porn is one of the few "safe" ways for young people to figure their junk out.

I'm not exactly an expert at either porn or in-the-flesh sex but... I've always been given to understand that they are quite different.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by GuiA on Monday December 31, 2012 @06:01PM (#4991252)
Porn is vast. You can find videos of pornstars exaggeratingly copulating, like you can find amateur videos of two 20-somethings having perfectly regular sex.

Both, if seeked out by the teenager, are a subset of a perfectly healthy sex-education (much more so than the very politically correct discourse that passes for sex-ed in the US these days).

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by sp332 on Monday December 31, 2012 @06:07PM (#4991269)
But how would an uninitiated teen know which ones are exaggerated and which are "regular"? It seems like watching porn would,not be,as stimulating as real sex, so people would seek out exaggerated videos which are not as, um, "educational".
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by jrockway on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @01:32PM (#4993380)
How do you know the sex you're having with your partner is "regular"?

The answer is intuition, and even teenagers have intuition.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by sp332 on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @02:19PM (#4993557)
"Regular" is strongly influenced, if not completely defined, by what you see around you. Porn might partly reflect what people want but it also definitely changes what they want. e.g. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1124922 People who watch porn are only learning how to make porn.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by vy8vWJlco on Tuesday January 01, 2013 @06:37PM (#4994494)
> "People who watch porn are only learning how to make porn."

That's a very narrow perspective. I can honestly say I have never felt like a porn actor (or director) in the bedroom because I watched porn as a teenager (to which I also attribute my ability to draw, FWIW...).

If there were magically a safe partner for everyone at all times, regardless or age or circumstance, I have no doubt there would be less porn. But we don't live in one of those worlds, we live in an emotionally-wrought, often isolating one. Teenagers feel alone, yet it's also a time when the instincts and cravings are the strongest, the most out of control, and the least satiable. The type of flirting and friendships I can take for granted, are not even on the table for them. Teenagers are still cutting their teeth on their communication skills. They don't know how to cope with a lot of things, one being the deeply-rooted drive to procreate. Pursuing those feelings safely can be difficult. Masturbation is one way for them to explore their feelings in the _safety_ of their own room - to take control of their feelings - without resorting to extremely poor decisions (unwanted pregnancies, unhealthy relationships, getting tattoos that claim they will love someone forever when all they really wanted was to see them naked...). Would a real partner be better? Perhaps. Is that always the best option? No, and I think it's harmful to act as though it were. Everyone has genitals and the feelings that go with them, but for better or worse, society pretends young people don't. For lack of a better term, they are screwed; they are on their own: they get to figure things out, hopefully without ruining their life in other ways.

Some forms of experimentation are more dangerous than others, and watching porn is one of the least dangerous options available to young people to explore their feelings. Ignoring that (prohibition, for example) won't help. Assuming we emphasize the difference between fantasy and reality, porn can serve a person well over the years. In that spirit, I would much rather see a "this film is fantasy, and does not necessarily reflect a healthy realtionship" warning on porn, rather than all those copyright threats... It's pretty obvious what our priorities are.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by cheald on Monday December 31, 2012 @06:00PM (#4991251)
Relying on porn to teach kids about sex is about as reasonable as relying on the Twilight movies to teach them about how to have healthy relationships.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by FuzzyDunlop on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:03PM (#4991080)
If it was in the UK it'd never happen anyway, unless the kid buys fake ID and sends the info to the network to enable adult content.

"You must not use this phone to falsely identify yourself as an 18 year old."

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by Tomdarkness on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:09PM (#4991104)
Depends what network you are on. I'm on 3 and you have to opt in to the filter, it is not enabled by default on contracts.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by k-mcgrady on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:56PM (#4991240)
That filter only applies to the network (E/3G/4G) not wifi. With ISP's those filters are still opt-in.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by sp332 on Monday December 31, 2012 @04:56PM (#4991056)
Porn never came up in a conversation with your parents? I don't mean on a regular basis but... even once?
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by enraged_camel on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:07PM (#4991096)
Not really. My parents knew that regardless of any rules or restrictions they would place on me, I'd find a way around them and watch porn anyway. So the subject was never brought up.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by dhimes on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:59PM (#4991248)
My father had equally pragmatic rules about alcohol and drugs. He made sure I was educated about the effects of drugs. He made sure that I knew that my mind was pretty awesome and putting it at risk is stupid. (He also knew that kids do such things- but try to be smart about it.) He told me my grades had to stay up and I couldn't lose my job. And he said that if the police came to the house and knew my name- if I was somehow involved enough in something and didn't have sense enough to get away- I would lose all of my freedom. Guilty or not. And if he ever caught me driving under the influence- the same.

I had a lot of freedom, and I made some mistakes, but overall it worked out.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by enraged_camel on Monday December 31, 2012 @06:26PM (#4991319)
I think that's a really good model for educating the kid, because it's actually a representation of how society at large works. We have lots of freedom, but if we abuse that freedom then we lose it. Driving licenses can be suspended or revoked for breaking traffic rules, hefty fines can be charged for misdemeanors, the individual can be imprisoned for more serious crimes, etc. Props to your dad.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by adulau on Monday December 31, 2012 @04:57PM (#4991060)
Or you'll be the one going the library (if there is still one around), concentrate on interesting thing to learn or do instead of re-sharing the video that all the child are sharing. Sometime you'll lack social tools like a mobile phone but you might learn and discover interest that might change your life afterward[1].

[1] I know you can discover stuff on your mobile phone but it's probable that you will just discover the mainstream culture.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by jrockway on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:19PM (#4991132)
Oh noes, "mainstream culture", how evil.

Anyway, phones are just a tool. People that want to do something other than read Facebook all day will do something other than read Facebook all day.

I had an unrestricted Internet connection when I was a kid. I used it to learn C++, Java, and Scheme. I also had a phone in high school (when I lived in Tokyo, it wasn't "a thing" in the US yet) and I never saw anyone excessively distracted by their phones.

My younger brother recently graduated from high school in an era where everyone had a phone. He still did homework and had interests outside of Facebook. So I think you're worrying about a problem that's not actually a problem.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by ary on Monday December 31, 2012 @04:55PM (#4991052)
"Everyone" also more or less blindly accepts the gradual stripping away of their liberty, the irresponsible destruction of the environment, and the nutritional content of fast food. Oddly enough it takes people unwilling to accept the status quo for anything to change.

Imagine that.

Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by archangel_one on Monday December 31, 2012 @05:26PM (#4991149)
The things you list there are obviously bad (assuming that by the last you refer to overconsumption of it), but I don't think it is equally obvious that teenagers having cellphones at school is a bad thing just because it's a recent development.
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by paigalhaes on Wednesday January 02, 2013 @11:20AM (#4997382)
cellphones at school is a bad thing when kids use it to only to text friends that are in the same space (the school), not talking in person and arrange commitments, and abundance of texting ends in empty talks when facing someone, losing sence of important social "skills" needed for life: and that's an important role of schools
Re:This mom gave her son an 18-point contract with his iPhone by vy8vWJlco on Monday December 31, 2012 @08:39PM (#4991577)
Isn't the reason you have a cell phone so people can reach you when you are out (for safety, for example)? Besides, if he can't take it to school, how can she geo-locate him?