News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What're You Reading? by computerdork on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @11:19PM (#49903988)
Re-read Crime and Punishment - read this as a teenager in high school, and (not suprisingly) think at the time had missed the main point behind it (and warning, if you haven't read it, spoilers ahead!).

When I was young, thought that Raskolnikov was an example of an intelligent, moral person who was struggling with higher concepts which led him to murder. And moreover back then, thought he was a overall a good protagnist who was just in an impossible situation.

Now, realized the novel is more about psychology and how people who are overall good and others who are overall bad make choices, and then they have to mentally deal with these decisions. Yeah, think Dostoevsky is saying Raskolnikov was actually very misguided in the reasoning behind his murders. Eventhough his intentions were in many respects actually good, they were egotistically and overly idealistic. Eventually, Raskonikov realized he had deluded himself and that he was hyperinflating his own merits and value as a person over other people. And also, at a more basically level, he struggled with his conscience on whether to avoid being caught, commit suicide or turn himself in. He himself didn't believe he was an immoral person, and when he realized he had deluded himself, he struggled in the end on what course of action to take.

One downside of the book is by today's standards, it is very long-winded and often take several pages to go through something that would take a single page by many writers today. But think this also makes it more realistic, because most people in actual life don't get to the point that quickly. Really fascinating.

Re:Ask HN: What're You Reading? by joeguilmette on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @11:39PM (#49904100)
I recently read this as well. Some passages were just fantastic and really captured the imagination and made you think and feel.

It’s a shame that, as you said, but modern standards the book has a lot of rough edges. If it were half as long it would be 10x better.

If you got through C&P unscathed, I’d *highly* recommend The Gambler. It is absolutely a modern, tight, fast paced thriller. It is a deep, disturbing look into addiction and compulsive behavior.

I found it as thought provoking and insightful as C&P but, crucially, I also enjoyed reading the whole thing.

Re:Ask HN: What're You Reading? by thatsnogood123 on Tuesday September 29, 2026 @11:24PM (#49904019)
i also re-read this as an adult after having read it in school and not really gotten it. I don't have any more talent for literary interpretation than back then, but it's funny how much more interesting everything is as an adult. The murder scene grabbed as well as any modern thriller.
Re:Ask HN: What're You Reading? by computerdork on Wednesday September 30, 2026 @11:24AM (#49910204)
Agreed, the murder scene is very realistic in its "make it up as you go along" feel to it. Really also liked the scene where Raskolnikov, after days of carrying the tremendous burden of guilt and shame of these murders, finally confesses what he did to Sonya. You could feel this enormous weight being lifted off his shoulders. Both great scenes.