News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chomsky: Work, Learning and Freedom by steveklabnik on Monday December 31, 2012 @12:52PM (#4990073)
> I have a hard time believing you've read any Marx. You're not doing his work very much justice.

First of all, socialism is bigger than Marx. You are absolutely correct in that Marx/Lennin would not think that business operating as socialist within a capitalist context would lead to revolution or communism. Luckily, I wasn't talking about that.

Secondarily, Marx never actually used the world 'socialism,' he did make a few passing references to 'lower communism' and 'lesser communism.' He _did_ critique the utopian socialists of his day for not being realistic enough.

Re:Chomsky: Work, Learning and Freedom by codewright on Monday December 31, 2012 @02:20PM (#4990468)
Lower communism is formally known as socialism among Marxist scholars. To say that Marx never spoke of socialism when the academic understanding has been that the terminology maps over is very misleading.

Marx & Engels criticized utopian socialism that was utopian for simply lacking a vision of bringing itself about. That's what made it utopian. Marx and Engels critiqued utopianism, market socialism, and liberal democracy, not socialism itself. To say that their critiques of dreamy, ungrounded utopianism were somehow a critique of one of the utopian hobby-horses (socialism) is...a severe misunderstanding of Marx.

They themselves saw the revolutionary state that would midwife the ushering in of Communism as being socialist by necessity. The Paris Commune would later serve to change Marx's attitude about the midwife state a bit though.

You're just compounding your misunderstandings and further propagating misinformation about Marx. Please stop. This isn't even about the original conversation for me anymore, I just want you to stop spreading untruths.

Re:Chomsky: Work, Learning and Freedom by steveklabnik on Monday December 31, 2012 @02:26PM (#4990495)
> To say that Marx never spoke of socialism when the academic understanding has been that the terminology maps over is very misleading.

What I was trying to communicate is that Marxism involves socialism, but socialism does not involve Marxism.

> Marx & Engels criticized utopian socialism that was utopian for simply lacking a vision of bringing itself about.

This is what I said. "not being realistic enough."

> They themselves saw the revolutionary state that would midwife the ushering in of Communism as being socialist by necessity. The Paris Commune would later serve to change Marx's attitude about the midwife state a bit though.

I agree 100%.

I really think we have a failure to communicate here, not an actual disagreement in understanding, now. Both me misunderstanding you and you misunderstanding me. You can understand why I'm naturally skeptical of anyone invoking Marx in this place. My apologies.