News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whiting Out the Ads, but at What Cost? by davidw on Tuesday September 04, 2007 @02:45AM (#49881)
By serving up some HTML, you're giving away content - you might have some rules about redistribution, of course, but esentially, you're giving some HTML and/or images to someone's browser to render as they see fit. If they choose to ignore or excise some of it, that's their business. For instance, screen readers for blind people ignore images.

I sympathize with the advertiser's point of view, because I have several sites myself that get a little bit of money from adsense. However, I'm enough of a believer in freedom to think that if people want to block ads more than they want free content, well, that's what the market will give them in some way or another.

Re:Whiting Out the Ads, but at What Cost? by steve on Tuesday September 04, 2007 @03:21PM (#50092)
You can't accept this practice as reasonable unless you accept that publishers can also block, or attempt to block, users who block ads.

If you ask me, both are fair game.

Re:Whiting Out the Ads, but at What Cost? by davidw on Tuesday September 04, 2007 @04:06PM (#50117)
Yeah, I agree. It's sort of an arms race - publishers might also try sneakier ways of slipping ads in. I have a feeling that 99% of users aren't going to get that excited about it unless the ads get overbearingly intrusive.