I agree with the idea of giving opportunities to smart kids from good families who work hard and are ethical. But I also think it's pretty damn hard to get good at certain things outside of a classroom? I don't know, I have mixed emotions.
Still, despite my misgivings with traditional education, I think there remains some good that comes from going to a place where your only job is to learn.
But none of the loans and none of the "go work for IBM" mentality that taught me how to be a loser for way too long.
A few years head start on actual business building is way more valuable than a 250 kid lecture hall with a teacher who never built anything in their life.
The future belongs to entrepreneurs, and that's even more true now with LLM built businesses.
Get them a face to face sales job for a bit. It does a lot for one's character to learn how to break the ice and be personable. And it teaches work ethic.
https://journals.sagepub.com/stoken/default+domain/W9MBX7ZGK...
"We estimate the internal rates of return (IRRs) for individuals with college degrees in 10 broad majors compared to high school graduates. Our analysis shows significant differences in the age-earnings trajectories and IRRs across college majors. Specifically, Computer Science and Engineering majors have the highest IRRs, exceeding 13%, whereas Humanities & Arts and Education majors have the lowest IRRs, around 5% for male and 8–9% for female college graduates. Furthermore, the quantile regression analyses show that IRR is generally higher at the high end of the earnings distribution. Finally, we observed a slight decrease in IRR during the study period, which is consistent with the flattening and even decline in college wage premiums following the 2008 Great Recession."
The fact that attending colleges requires certain abilities and privileges that also correlate with financial success doesn't say anything about the influence that college has on earnings.
For all we know, the fact that college direction is ingrained in a public education system that is required by law, hides the fact that college has a negative impact on one's financial product when taken over a lifetime.
The same people that think college might pan out, also think loans for businesses, or other such behaviors that exhibit initiative, might pan out. We'd expect those same traits in leaders and entrepreneurs, and we'd expect them to be paid more.
Plainly, the claim is misguided and its dissemination, I suspect, is most likely driven by profits.
The data is very extensive on this point. You are handwaving away a bunch of science on this, and throwing shade on researchers without anything more than a "yeah, they would say that." That's very weak sauce.
If you want to make a case, at least cite some evidence
Not sure what your sources are. The roi for disadvantaged students is lower than it is for richer students, but still positive across the vast majority of outcomes.
To make a good experiment you'd need to control for the presence of college in society. The fact that it exists and takes credit for the work of people who would already be doing what it purports to cause makes it impossible to conceive of such a study.
It's just like a church claiming responsibility for human morality, where everyone starts with a church forced on them. Likewise the church will show studies on criminal behavior and drug addicts, and of course, we will find success in their work. God really does save then, right?
I'm not religious, I'm a scientist.
Sure enough lots of people are moral even without the church, and lots of people are incredibly successful, even without college.
And those examples lend themselves to reasoning deductively about the facts, a much higher logical bar when weighing what is or isn't worth believing in.
That's true as far as the latest arguments on the philosophy of science. So I'm perfectly comfortable waving away illogical arguments, and giving less weight to inductive ones, even if they include lots of marketing and other sound research.
It's more worth believing in because it's more logically sound. So no, the sauce is not weak when compared to your faith based argument.
The research you provided shows that we might expect some people to benefit from college. Sure. But to prescribe it for everyone, is clearly a mistake. It's bad for many famous examples, and it's bad for countless more of us who now lead companies in fields we didn't study.
As a side note, for others out there pedaling this lie, it's offensive and dismissive to act like repaying such a huge debt over 20 years is a win. I sweat and struggled, and ate trash for your lies.
Your lies did that to me. Take responsibility for that, and think carefully, before you go convincing other kids to follow in my footsteps.
The system forces schools to increase enrollment by assigning a tuition price based on attaching a loan to it. It's basically for profit. Then, the loans can't be forgiven in bankruptcy when the outcome of the education platform fails to produce an income that supports repayment.
To get an education that doesn't completely screw you over, you need to be a minority with a scholarship or actually have rich parents and attend for fun. But in either case, your only benefit financially is the hope of connecting with other students whose parents are richer than yours.
Exceptions for subjects with artificial barriers of entry (medicine, law, etc., and each of those has its own set of problems, mainly the price of education).
(Speaking about the United States, but probably a lot of this applies to many places.)
I disagree with the sentiment that the rich are dissuading college enrollment. I'm not rich. I don't hire college grads. They are broke, entitled, and lack work ethic. After 5 in a row, I started giving opportunities to smart kids, from good families, who exhibit an appreciation for hard work and good moral character. Those people learn in a month what takes a college grad 6. They appreciate opportunity, instead of expecting it.
As I should have always known, a good person is far, far more valuable than a piece of paper certifying victimhood.