News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Test by edent on Friday September 25, 2026 @01:42PM (#49847689)
That's not an interview, that's at best stenography and at worse sycophancy.

If, for example, an interviewee said in all seriousness "I want to shoot all dogs and make the poor eat their babies" would you expect the interviewer to go go "Hmmm very interesting. Why do you think that?"

No.

It is vital that interviewers challenge the subject. Especially when they say something profoundly ludicrous or disturbing. Otherwise they might has well just be in PR.

Re:The Test by pigpop on Friday September 25, 2026 @02:43PM (#49848343)
You can have different types of interview, they don't all have to be permissive or challenging. If someone said "I want to shoot all dogs and make the poor eat their babies" during a podcast interview what good is it going to do for the interviewer to challenge that? The interviewee has already declared something horrendous, telling them they're beyond the pale on the spot is unlikely to change anything. Asking them why would be much more valuable since they could expose more of their deranged fantasies (at least in this scenario) which would subject them to even more revulsion and scrutiny by listeners. If you watch police interrogations this is often the tactic used even in the most horrendous crimes. They aren't confrontational, they don't denounce, they often don't even challenge inconsistencies at first. They let people speak and encourage them to say more or go over something they talked about previously in more detail. It appears almost friendly or compassionate to a casual observer but they're really just giving the subject more rope to hang themselves with.
Re:The Test by edent on Friday September 25, 2026 @03:04PM (#49848586)
If you publish a podcast where your guest encourages heinous behaviour without you challenging - that's a you problem.

Saying "Well, our listeners can decide for themselves" is a cowardly cop-out.

You might not be able to change the interviewee's mind but you can sure as hell send social signals to your audience that you condemn their views or think they're ludicrous.

Case in point - why are you trying to change my mind here? You're pushing back because you want to signal to others that my point of view is incorrect. That sort of basic interrogation seems completely missing in (especially American) media.

Re:The Test by pigpop on Friday September 25, 2026 @03:15PM (#49848701)
You're assigning motives to me that I don't have. Maybe that is the distinction, you think how you appear to an audience is important, I'm viewing this no differently than I would a private conversation. I'm not performing or signalling to anyone.
Re:The Test by edent on Friday September 25, 2026 @03:19PM (#49848746)
Why are you pushing back at me in a private conversation then?

Why wouldn't you do the same if I said something outrageously offensive in public?

Re:The Test by pigpop on Friday September 25, 2026 @03:39PM (#49848981)
This really isn't the same thing as an interview. I'm not talking to you for the benefit of an audience or as a way to document your thoughts. I'm saying what I think and responding to what you think (and accuse me of thinking). I'm expressing my own opinion, I'm not trying to win a debate or make myself look good.
Re:The Test by wtobey1 on Friday September 25, 2026 @02:04PM (#49847939)
No it’s not. There’s a trade off to make between letting someone explain themselves and challenging them. The audience has their own braincells and can make their own decisions on what they are hearing.

Actually yes if a interviewee said something like that I’d like to know why they’re saying that because it doesn’t make sense to me!

Re:The Test by edent on Friday September 25, 2026 @03:07PM (#49848626)
If a leading politician says something deranged like "all crime is caused by gay people" - should the newspaper simply report that verbatim? Or should they say "the President lied today, and here are the facts that shows he is wrong"?

Sometimes it helps for institutions to point out the the emperor has no clothes. The social reinforcement of norms is hugely influential.

Re:The Test by wtobey1 on Friday September 25, 2026 @04:53PM (#49849809)
Reporting and interviewing are completely different exercises with different goals and motivations.
Re:The Test by edent on Friday September 25, 2026 @06:38PM (#49850882)
OK. If you interview the President and he repeatedly lies - is it OK to just publish that interview? Or should you push back on those lies? Do you owe it to your audience to let them know the king is mad?

The risk, of course, is that you don't get invited back. That's "The Test" in the post.