As long as numbers like these hold true: "At the $1 RPM (CPM/CPA/CPC) level achieved by most general sites, you need 4 billion page views/month ... to [reach] $50M in revenue per year" (http://www.thealarmclock.com/mt/archives/2007/03/a_vcs_view_...), charging money for a product that creates value is going to be a more viable way of starting a successful company online
Getting big and targeted is a lot more expensive (and highly competitive, see gadgets, etc.) than getting big and general, since it usually means non-user generated content.
If a company like firefox implemented ad blocking by default, they'd be doing the web a huge favor. Unlike pop-up blocking, firefox would be killing the only revenue sources for the majority of today's popular websites. Sure, it's easy to say that more companies should focus on getting 'real' business models, but a web in which _every_ professional web site required a subscription fee would be totally impractical.
It will be very cool, however, to see how the micropayments industry challenges advertising. While it's unlikely CNN will every jump on it, what if some of the more adventurous sites ditched advertising in favor of a donation box model?
The thing is, people thought ad-skipping technology was unlikely until tivo came out and made it usable. I don't imagine it will be too long before someone comes out and does this, and if they execute well, it would be devastating to the industry.
AdBlock blocks some adverts. It's useless blocking a large amount of adverts.
If it comes installed, adverts will all just change and it'll be rendered useless.
You can't draw parallels with TiVo. Video adverts prevent you getting to see the content you want. You have to wait. Internet advertising does not do this. It's just additional information.
Edit: This could be thought of like an analogy to spyware detectors, i.e. ad-aware. They have a ton of custom detectors, which are continually updated to classify spyware. I would certainly pay for a commercial free web.
I'd rather not have an arms race, but if there is one, it's pretty obvious who would win.
And, combined with a better managed, ugc version of http://adblockplus.org/en/subscriptions would certainly be unstoppable.
How do you block those ads? How do you know it's an ad and not just a link.
The difference between a link and ad can be nothing to observers. (obviously intrusive ads are another matter)
You could also scan all outbound links and check to see if content (actual content) is the same without the parameters (e.g. my.affiliate.com/?affid=134 == my.affiliate.com or aff123.affiliate.com == www.affiliate.com) simply based on a few heuristics.
I am thinking something like a combination of opendns + adblock + digg would work in a nice slick package so that grandmas can use it.
Make something people want. People don't really care if someone gets commission. In fact they often go out of their way to make the website commission if they like what the website does.
I do think it's something people want too. Distraction is a huge problem on the web. I know it's not what you want being an ad supported business, but I do believe someone will do it at some point.
Lets say you create some webapp that you charge $20/mo for. To get to $50M a year, you need to get 200,000 paying customers.
The question then is what is harder to achieve, 200k paying customers, or 4bn page views/month.
-$20/mo.
Personally though in my experience of consumer based websites, making money from advertising is 'easy'. Orders of magnitude easier than getting someone to reach for their wallet.
That being said, for every (EDIT:ok, most) struggling consumer startup you show me, I can show you a way they can apply their technology in different fields and charge customers.
We just have to stop being afraid to say "Pay Me Please".
ISPs should have micropayment systems that add charges to your bill - just like when you SMS a shortcode, it gets added to your cellphone bill.
This would massively change things on the web.
At the moment though, the hurdle is just way too high for consumers. The effort required to get someone to pay you $10 isn't even in the same ballpark as the effort required to make $10 from advertising.
There's millions to be made from advertising revenue. If you can get people to pay for something, great, but not every product is the type where paying would make any sense at all. By charging consumers directly, you massively reduce your audience to a small subset of users.
It's quite funny to see people imply that advertising revenue isn't "real" revenue, or is in some way less valuable than getting customers to pay directly.
You know what the most powerful marketing word in the world is? "FREE". The clever thing is using that to your advantage and still making money. Tons of industries do that though, loss leaders work, 'free cellphone (with contract) works' etc etc.