A human can't tell if it halts either, friend. A simulation of that human will follow the same infinite step calculation and they will behave identically. Physics can be simulated in finite time to any degree of accuracy.
I hear how passionately you want to believe these things. Unfortunately they're not true. I suggest you look into it.
Or a program that knocks out a bottle when it finds a counter example for whatever . U can’t tell whether it will spill the liquid.
And you have as well the problems of approximating the continuous with bits, you’ll always lose information