News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:33AM (#49812030)
I mean, will it be normalized? By the way rates are going it seems quite the opposite.

And your other examples don't quite work. Interracial marriage has been allowed in many places (if not most places) throughout history, and even female suffrage was a thing in some polities. Homosexual marriage is not a something that's ever really been practiced in its current form until basically the 1970s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same-sex_marriage

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by lunchbucket on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:47AM (#49812113)
> Interracial marriage has been allowed in many places (if not most places) throughout history, and even female suffrage was a thing in some polities.

You do understand that they were referring to the places it was disallowed? LGTBQ people and same sex marriage have also been tolerated in some times and places (even before the 70s).

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:56AM (#49812168)
> LGTBQ people and same sex marriage

While homosexuality has been accepted in many nations and cultures before the modern day, gay marriage including custodianship over children is basically a 21st century invention.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by maxbond on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @02:19AM (#49812353)
Same sex marriage has been allowed in a number of societies throughout history. There are a number of examples here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_same-sex_unions

It's not a "21st century invention," not even because it has a longer history than that, but because it's just marriage. It isn't an innovation. Any more than women's suffrage was an innovation. In both cases it's extending enfranchisement to more people.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:02PM (#49822562)
Your article is literally saying what I'm saying. I agree with you... homosexual partnerships are common, but claiming that they were the equivalent of marriage is ahistoric:

> At the same time, many of these relationships might be more clearly understood as mentoring relationships between adult men and young boys rather than an analog of marriage.

Of the western world it says:

> Conubium existed only between a civis Romanus and a civis Romana (that is, between a male Roman citizen and a female Roman citizen), so that a marriage between two Roman males (or with a slave, amasius) would have no legal standing in Roman law (apart, presumably, from the arbitrary will of the emperor in the two aforementioned cases)

Of China:

> While the relationship was clearly approved by the wider community, and was compared to heterosexual marriage, it did not involve a religious ceremony binding the couple.

Of early modern times:

> Michel de Montaigne, a 16th-century French philosopher and prominent essayist, reports having heard a third-party description of a same-sex wedding occurring some years earlier using the usual Tridentine marriage ceremonies of the Roman Catholic Church. The ceremony was said to have occurred a few years before 1581, at the San Giovanni a Porta Latina basilica in Rome and the participants were burned at the stake by the Vatican

It then claims Anne Lister married Ann Walker, but if you read the article detailing this marriage, there wasn't any sanctioned ceremony. Rather the two women took communion together and thereafter they considered themselves married. There was no socially sanctioned recognition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_Lister#Relationship_with_...

> Eventually the women took communion together on Easter Sunday (30 March) 1834 in Holy Trinity Church, Goodramgate, York, and thereafter considered themselves married, but without legal recognition.

It literally says all this in your article. Did you read it?

The only references to pre-modern homosexual marriage are hearsay reports of Siwa oasis and the Phillipines. Neither of these cite written records or any sort of proof, and both of these would have been in somewhat literate societies.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by wyre on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:44AM (#49812095)
What do you mean the way rates are going? Homosexuality has existed for as long as there have been humans.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:55AM (#49812164)
I'm talking about approval for gay marriage not homosexuality. Obviously homosexuality is ancient. Homosexual marriage in the modern sense is absent from the historical record until 1971. Where it was portrayed it was typically as a joke .

I'm being down voted but I have no real stance on this. If anything I'm in favor of civil rights for all, but I don't see how that changes the historical record. Gay marriage is a novelty compared to female suffrage and interracial marriage.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by lemmetellya on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @02:03AM (#49812222)
Interracial marriage was federally protected in 2022, and only permitted by court opinion in 1967 in the US. You better believe it was not socially acceptable in much of the South just because the court said it was legal.

Heck, I bet there are communities today where you cannot safely live if you have an interracial marriage. I don't think it's as solved as you suggest.

I lived in a lefty urban environment in the 90s and recall many people telling me I wasn't allowed to date noon write women.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:08PM (#49822652)
There is more to 'the world' than America. America was an aberration for legislating marriage so closely. Consider that someone in India in the 1800s would have thought that caste simply 'was', whereas the rest of the world would have been shocked by it. Similarly, anti-miscegenation laws, while common in America, and easy to think of as 'normal' from an American perspective, were not that common. Almost every culture normally socially approved of a man taking on a foreign wife, and most cultures welcomed foreign men who adapted into it marrying a local woman. There are countless examples from almost every part of the globe. It wasn't exactly uncommon. For the last two thousand years, the largest religions on the planet, would have supported a man and woman of different races to be married. Neither Catholicism nor Orthodoxy nor Islam nor Hinduism nor Buddhism (which together constitute the vast majority of the world) would have ever had any issues with interracial marriage. In fact, they would have encouraged it against a non-believer of the respective traditions. Not a single one would have supported gay marriage.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by maxbond on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @02:47AM (#49812529)
You're taking a fairly strong stance, though it may not seem that way to you. "Same sex marriage was legalized in 1971" is a factual statement not in dispute. "Same sex marriage is a 21st century invention" may seem to you to be the same statement but it carries significant ideological baggage and is a way stronger statement way more in dispute. You go on to say things like "the real reason behind a lot of the LGBT acceptance rates going lower ... is that Muslim migrants have more kids and Islam is a very socially conservative religion." I hardly feel I need to explain why that is not a simple factual statement but really a statement of an ideological and political position.

So while I totally believe you may feel that way, you aren't simply being downvoted for indisputable facts, you've taken a position in a contentious ideological and political debate.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:11PM (#49822684)
There is no debate. If someone were to point out a written record of an actual marriage that is using equivalent rites to a heterosexual marriage with exact legal recognition of that contract plus additionally rights over children, I will relent. This is not some ideological position. It's simply an absence of any such thing. For example, it should not be controversial to say that surrogacy is a modern day thing and that there is no historic record prior to it of a woman being considered the biological mother of a child she didn't bear. People are having their feelings about gay marriage override simple historical fact.

The Wikipedia page on the history of gay marriage makes the exact same point I've made. My statement is not controversial and is the accepted view. There are countless examples of gay people considering themselves married, but without societal recognition equivalent to heterosexual marriage. You cannot consider this the same as gay marriage because gay rights activists said that similar arrangements in the modern day were not enough and they needed to be married in an equivalent fashion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_same-sex_unions

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by easyThrowaway on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @04:36AM (#49813216)
We have historical proof of homosexual marriage dating back to imperial Rome. IIRC the latest acknowledged homosexual union before modern times goes back to early 1500, before it started being prosecuted more aggressively by the catholic church.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:09PM (#49822662)
There is no proof of homosexual marriage in imperial Rome. 'Marriage' as we practice it today does not have a direct analogue in Rome, but all the institutions one could point to that could be likened to it explicitly stated it was between a male and female. Can you please provide written proof? If it is common, it should not be hard to find in the extremely prolific writings of the Romans.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by easyThrowaway on Thursday September 24, 2026 @05:41AM (#49828329)
> Can you please provide written proof?

Was wikipedia too much of a hassle?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagoras_(freedman) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elagabalus

If you can understand italian I can suggest you Alessandro Barbero's Podcast, it's a pretty famous historian, there are several episodes about the topic.

I know where you're getting at - Not really the modern equivalent, only for the rich part of the population, contrasting opinions from historian at the time, etc.

But frankly the same objections could be raised even about the equally famous "did Ancient romans have running water in their homes?" question, and yet for some weird reason it's a far less controversial topic.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Thursday September 24, 2026 @09:12PM (#49839010)
None of these were legal marriages. Of course anyone can stage whatever they want. This has always been legal even here in the US. The articles point out that no one actually held the emperor married to these men and just put it up to the emperor's eccentricity.

Moreover in the case of elagabalus, it's possible the stories were made up to discredit him and if they weren't made up they were highly scandalous and not at all well accepted. Forget marriage, even the insinuation he had slept with men was considered too scandalous to mention..

> Elagabalus had nothing at all to make up for his vices, which are of such a kind that it is too disgusting even to allude to them

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @01:48AM (#49812124)
And the church and its conservative patriarchal misogynist homophobic dogma ruled all our lives for centuries. But it turns out you can beat the church, if you prove to people that there's no invisible man in the sky watching everything you do, dinosaur bones weren't planted here 6,000 years ago, and gay people are actually normal people that are just slightly different. Conservatives may be depending on hate to keep their numbers up, but that's all they have now.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @02:00AM (#49812199)
Once again, I'm not sure this is true. Perhaps the Catholic Church is beaten and relegated to the dustbin of history. The article fails to mention the real reason behind a lot of the LGBT acceptance rates going lower, which is that Muslim migrants have more kids and Islam is a very socially conservative religion.

So maybe you beat the Catholics but is there enough willpower to defeat the Muslims?

Again, you're assuming I'm sort of social conservative pariah. I'm not.

> and gay people are actually normal people that are just slightly different

Once again you're trying to convince me instead of the children of the Netherlands. Good luck.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by richardsp on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @02:09AM (#49812267)
Your analysis is correct. Personally, I think that Islam getting the western left to embrace it as part of "the oppressed" has been the most successful social social movement of the last 20 years.

https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2025/09/a-muslim-majority-city-b...

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @09:38AM (#49815989)
I don't need to convince anyone. That's my point. The trend is toward liberalism in general, across the globe, despite outliers. Plenty of academic study backs this up, if you care to research it.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @05:07PM (#49822635)
There is no trend towards liberalism except in western nations, and even that is debatable. People operate under this assumption that everything magically becomes more liberal. It doesn't. There have been regressions and progressions. Progress is not guaranteed.

> Plenty of academic study backs this up, if you care to research it.

With all due respect to the academics, there is more to the world than the Western world and most academics in the West have no ability to comprehend the East. I say this as someone whose family is from 'the East' and so I think I have some more insight into it than many people do. The simple truth is that about 3.1 billion people alone live in India and China and the majority of people in the world live outside the West and these areas are not seeing any sort of great social progress. Sure, there's a lot of economic progress, but social progress in the Western sense is absent (progress in the non-western sense is continuing). There is no evidence that any of these countries are any more closer to embracing gay marriage than they were before. On the periphery of the west, such as the island of Bermuda, they actually repealed gay marriage. Even California, if they were to ask the voters, would repeal gay marriage due to the presence of Asians, Hispanics and blacks, who voted against it the last time they were asked.

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @07:05PM (#49823881)
Something for you to consider: if you genuinely believe you have more expert & accurate knowledge than dozens of people who have each spent their entire career studying a subject including doing years-long scientific studies on it, then either you're a genius or you severely overestimate yourself.
Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by anon291 on Thursday September 24, 2026 @12:25AM (#49826238)
how do you do a 'scientific' study on a historical question? Did they simulate multiple worlds and do statistical analyses to see how societies develop? Of course not... this is an archaeological/historical question not a scientific one.

> accurate knowledge than dozens of people

Yes, if you look at experts outside the main Western academic circles, they're pretty much in agreement about it.

> either you're a genius or you severely overestimate yourself.

Actually, my main superpower is reading

Re:LGBT tolerance slumps in the Netherlands as debate turns ... by 0xbadcafebee on Thursday September 24, 2026 @02:47PM (#49835138)
Armchair experts assume they're right based on what they read. They never have to face reality - whether what they think is actually right or wrong by testing it in the real world.

You can believe whatever you want to believe. You can believe the moon is made of cheese. You can live your whole life with that idea and be perfectly fine. Doesn't mean the moon is actually made of cheese.

Assuming that you're right without testing your idea is how you get moon cheese.