News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by tencentshill on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @01:27PM (#49804949)
What an amazing excuse for lower than expected performance! Our models are slow because we're so ethical.
Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by PaulStatezny on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @03:15PM (#49806650)
Thanks for spelling out what the original comment was implying.

I find it bizarre how intensely a bunch of these child/grandchild comments are criticizing the notion that people would even think to analyze the meaning behind the words.

Hacker News has always had a unique culture in which thoughtful discussion is basically the main goal, and it's intentionally incentivized in numerous ways. It's been my experience that any thoughts added to a post's conversation are seen as valuable as long as they are thoughtful and seeking to understand.

So these comments are clearly coming from a place that's antithetical to HN's culture. What that in mind, it seems likely to me (Occam's Razor) that these comments are either:

1. Astroturfing: Claude employees acting like everyday folks, secretly trying to shift public opinion.

2. AI cult mindset: "AI is humanity's salvation; how dare you have perspectives outside of those accepted by the cult."

Am I missing another likely option?

To bolster my point, right now we're posting on the top top-level comment, meaning a majority of active HN users find it to be a great addition to the conversation. Commenting to shut down the discussion is a red flag.

Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by nananana9 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @12:42AM (#49811733)
> Am I missing another likely option?

The website is way more popular than before and it's all but taken over by the Twitter AI grifter class.

Many of the people who used to parttake in the interesting discussuons I came here for, have gotten tired of 80% of the posts at any given time being about the brand new AGI LLM that's so much better than last week's AGI LLM, and have left months ago.

Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by Multicomp on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @12:57PM (#49819087)
> Many of the people who used to parttake in the interesting discussuons I came here for, have gotten tired of 80% of the posts at any given time being about the brand new AGI LLM that's so much better than last week's AGI LLM, and have left months ago.

I hope you are wrong, or rather, that HN's userbase can keep renewing itself on cycles of new users without getting into an eternal september situation. It's none of my affair (and yes, lately HN AI threads read suspiciously airheaded in tone, like they fell out of /r/codex and Grok-heavy online circles) overall, but I'd be curious if dang or whoever can easily get an idea as to what the current population of HN weekly/daily active users are and if that bag of users is similar to a year over year or decade over decade cohort. X% of our users are more than 10 years old, and so on.

But the above is an idle thought experiment, back to your point, there's definitely some bandwagon work going on, astroturfing and bot-controlled no doubts there too, and if I find one more Rationalist / Effective Altruist / AI doomer cult post, I may find a way to ship them 10 virtual spam palettes because there's more to the web than 'AI-chatterbox-class who's never actually read Neuromancer or Snow Crash or the meatier works of Asimov act superior to the rest of us' strawmen I have confirmation bias running into, yet overall, I still find HN has that spark here and there.

> Alice: ABC-library stinks, why did they write it that way? > Bob Reply: Hi there, yak here, I wrote it because Dennis Ritchie was sick with a cold and we needed it for Los Alamos Labs.

Those gold moments keep me here still.

Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by felixgallo on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @01:43PM (#49805243)
in what way is beating every other frontier model with their own second-tier model, 'lower than expected performance'? Please be specific.
Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by staticman2 on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @02:42PM (#49806133)
Why would the expected performance be relative to other models?
Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by felixgallo on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @05:22PM (#49808287)
are you really arguing that opus 5.5 beating the best of openai's models handily is worse than you expected? What exactly were you basing your expectations on?
Re:Claude Opus 5.5 by staticman2 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @07:36AM (#49814515)
This has nothing to do with me personally. How much did they spend on the new models and how much better are they? Was it worth the investment?

What did they promise their investors who invested billions?