Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by noibl on Friday December 28, 2012 @11:07PM
(#4981081)
> moves the goalposts to suggest Obama abandoned that objective by casting a yea vote that indemnified telcos for (a) lawful surveillance (b) conducted under the color of an entirely new statute in (c) a bill that mostly consisted of new limitations on FISA surveillance powers.
On (a), how or why can one be indemnified for lawful activity?
The bill to which Greenwald refers does in fact grant retroactive immunity from lawsuits seeking to show that the telco's participation was unlawful.[1] Such lawsuits would occur because other parties to the activity are protected by other mechanisms.
On (b), not sure what you mean by 'under the color of'. Hopefully not a reference to retroactive legalisation.
(c) doesn't seem at all relevant to the specific point here.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by tptacek on Friday December 28, 2012 @11:23PM
(#4981108)
I don't know how to respond to this comment, but would like to point out that these CRS memos (I've read a bunch of them today) are so. great. We really need to bump up the budget for the CRS.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by noibl on Friday December 28, 2012 @11:27PM
(#4981118)
That's OK. Sneering non-responses are also informative.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by tptacek on Friday December 28, 2012 @11:54PM
(#4981182)
I hope you're not saying I provided a sneering response. I was trying to express appreciation for the link you offered.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by noibl on Friday December 28, 2012 @11:59PM
(#4981192)
Thanks for clarifying. In the context of not addressing the question over Greenwald's credibility it looked sarcastic to me. You see, it's very confusing if you express appreciation for something that seems to contradict your point but then don't address the contradiction.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by joshuahedlund on Friday December 28, 2012 @07:55PM
(#4980471)
I appreciate your graciously thorough response. Judging from this and other comments, are we all agreed then that the "programmatic" surveillance is quite concerning? Am I correct in understanding that even though it's not supposed to "intentionally" target US citizens, they can't even provide an estimate of how many citizens have been included, implying that perhaps many citizens in fact have been?
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by tptacek on Friday December 28, 2012 @08:28PM
(#4980569)
Sure, programmatic surveillance is concerning, and oversight is good, and more of it is needed. But people in this debate tend to forget that we are debating the oversight of our spies. How much transparency do we expect?
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by neumann_alfred on Saturday December 29, 2012 @11:20AM
(#4982458)
Spies? I'd call it Secret Police.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by tptacek on Saturday December 29, 2012 @01:18PM
(#4982858)
... why would you call it "secret police"?
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by neumann_alfred on Saturday December 29, 2012 @01:27PM
(#4982894)
Because that's what espionage against your own citizens, under the pretext of defense against external threats, for the purpose of defense from external threats and bespoke citizens, is.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by tptacek on Saturday December 29, 2012 @08:49PM
(#4984209)
No, it isn't. You need to read more about the East German and Soviet Secret Police.
Re:Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
by neumann_alfred on Sunday December 30, 2012 @07:24AM
(#4985496)
Yes, it is. You need to read more about how Sweden does espionage. See how that works?
In other words, Greenwald invented an entirely new promise for Obama ("I will filibuster any bill that indemnifies telcos for any reason in concert with surveillance of any sort") and then cited him for a "blatant, unblinking violation of his own clear promise".
The lede of the cited article is incorrect, misleading, and pointlessly and unproductively political.
Next graf: continuation of same broken argument. Still no details about what the 2008 FISA Amendments Act actually said.
Next graf: invocation of Dick Cheney (the Democrats controlled the US Senate when the FISA Amendments Act passed, and Jay Rockefeller is no political ally of Cheney's; evidence for Cheney's actual input in the act: zero). Still no details about what the 2008 FISA Amendments Act actually said.
Next graf: multiple misrepresentations about the purpose of the FISA court and the conduct the Bush administration conducted that provoked outrage. Still no details about the 2008 FISA Amendments Act, which, contra the actual text of the article so far, specifically forbids the government from intentionally targeting American persons or persons residing in America.
Next graf: dishonestly conflates Wyden's proposals for increased accountability with Paul's showboating attempt to rewrite all existing rules regarding electronic communications to exempt any such communications stored in Google; in other words, foreign powers would be immune from spying so long as they used GMail.
Next graf: begins with "consider how modest these amendments are". Continues with suggestions that all the amendments he's mentioned are reasonable and well-thought-out. Note again here that Wyden himself didn't offer an amendment that required warrants for foreign intelligence or individualized suspicion for programmatic intercepts.
Next graf: still not having directly explained any of the contents of the 2008 FISA Amendments bill, Greenwald predictably fails to mention that the NSA is already forbidden by that bill from surveilling US targets when he mentions Wyden's bill requiring warrants for surveillance of US targets. Here Greenwald again carefully lawyers the words "US Soil" to implicate the idea that the NSA is spying on Americans. Merkley's amendment, "modest" by clear implication, suggests that a court whose purpose is to ensure that spies are spying on foreign targets and not Americans should be compelled to release the details on American spying to the public.
Next graf: no problems, straightforwardly confirms that the Administration opposes amendments that would have the net effect of immediately halting in-process foreign surveillance operations.
Next graf: Dianne Feinstein is now "conservative-Democratic" despite 100% ratings from reproductive rights groups, environmental groups, the Human Rights Campaign, arts groups, and, according to Votesmart, an 87% score from the ACLU. Why? because Feinstein supports something Greenwald opposes, falling into his no-true-Scotsman trap.
Next graf: Obama relied on Republicans (the "root of all evil") for an act that passed overwhelmingly.
Next graf: the 2008 FISA Amendments act, which Greenwald still hasn't discussed in detail, is now a "massive increase" in the government's surveillance powers, when in fact by statute it limits those powers; the "massive increase" comes from statutory authority to conduct programmatic surveillance of foreign nationals without individual findings for each person involved, a detail you can count on Greenwald not to share with you.
Next two grafs are quotes, but check your wallet after reading them.
Next graf: the 2008 FISA bill is flawed (sure), and Obama demands its renewal "without a single change". No: Obama failed to support any of the amendments offered for the bill, which is obviously not the same thing as a refusal to entertain any changes to the act at all.
Next graf: Rand Paul's "modest" amendment to the PATRIOT act, which would have exempted gun dealers (and nobody else) from PATRIOT-motivated subpoenas. Greenwald doesn't take the time to tell you what this amendment was because he would sound stupid explaining that in late December 2012. Also: Harry Reid is Dick Cheney.
Next two grafs are quotes.
Next graf: "if you try to debate the PATRIOT act", for instance by proposing a last-minute amendment exempting gun dealers from subpoenas in terrorism investigations, Reid suggests you support the terrorists. Of course, in neither of the preceding two quoted grafs does Reid say anything like this.
Next graf: plutocratic Dianne Feinstein, instrument of the national security state (with an 87% ACLU scorecard) is similarly demonizing people with concerns about the 2008 FISA Amendments act.
Here I give up. By all means. Cite Greenwald as if he's an objective source.