News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Attention is all you have by Karrot_Kream on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @06:45AM (#49799165)
I think bookmarks, files, and folders (to nostrademons point) is too coarse an abstraction for different organization domains. Music ks a good example. Most people want to organize by album, artist, year, genre, or song title. Files and folders or bookmark trees can mimic that structure but can't replace it. I like to order my photos by outing or by subject.

In either cases while you can reify your organizational system into files and folders it's just inferior to a personal classification system.

Re:Attention is all you have by TeMPOraL on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @08:14AM (#49800013)
Personal classification is key, I guess, because your two examples are alien to me.

> Music ks a good example. Most people want to organize by album, artist, year, genre, or song title.

I assumed this is because that's what software is limited to, and people cope, and the only people who really organize like that were the record stores owners. Because personally, this in no way even resembling how I think of my music collection, or how I pick what to listen to.

For me it's usually by theme, personal "feels like they belong together" connection, causal relationships (e.g. music from the same trip I went to in high school), or artist but defined loosely, I.e. tolerant of the fact that artists collaborate and perform together.

> I like to order my photos by outing or by subject.

Outing, yes, but by-subject is alien to me. Most of my photos have exactly zero people, or anywhere from 2 to 20+. Single subject photos are oddity, and I rarely feel the need to organize by them. Events, then by date, then maybe by location.

In both cases search turns out to be the answer, but with photos it's phenomenally unreliable due to vendor fucking with or stripping metadata.

Re:Attention is all you have by Karrot_Kream on Thursday September 24, 2026 @12:43AM (#49826346)
Yeah I do think the key is personal organization.

> Outing, yes, but by-subject is alien to me.

Hah seeing other photographers' Lightroom tags is always a trip. I know folks that even organize by exposure stops since they're after a certain look.

Re:Attention is all you have by nostrademons on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @12:47PM (#49804229)
I think the best approach is still files with embedded metadata (eg. EXIF for images/videos, ID3v2 for MP3s, resource forks in classic MacOS apps). That way you store, organize, and move around the content as a unit, and then you can display it in whatever way you want. And you can write new apps to display things differently as consumer tastes change.