Re:Freicoin: a P2P digital currency delivering freedom from ...
by mindslight on Friday December 28, 2012 @05:15PM
(#4979893)
If you can't be confident that an exchange (blind token signing key) will hold value for the long term, the exchanges are really only functioning as short-term mixes for some 'real' currency (as you describe), and the problem remains creating a currency issuer that won't eventually work to prevent anonymous transactions.
In your described system, the issuers still face the fundamental problem of having to have a good reputation, but being unable to obtain this reputation in the standard way (real-world identity in a powerful "rule of law" jurisdiction), lest the delegator 'discourage' them from facilitating anonymous transactions. Multiple competing issuers do not help the situation due to the catastrophic failure mode of each - bank run and worthless currency.
Creating a widespread reputation that isn't derived from real-world identity is the problem that bitcoin is attempting to solve, which is why the novel part of it is solving a coordination problem and not a problem from cryptography.
The exchange itself doesn't need to be particularly trusted; you could do a transaction either instantaneous and of low value, or some more complex protocol. There's also no inherent monopoly for the exchange, although there's a natural monopoly for any given pair of currencies.
Assuming everything is automated and low friction, you could be in and out of a given currency to make a transaction pretty fast, so arbitrarily short risk. You could split transactions up into smaller transactions so arbitrarily low financial risk per transaction.