News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by jlongr on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:36AM (#49788662)
There's this prevailing narrative that someday self-driving cars will eliminate all human-controlled driving and that these types of stories are like milestones in the path to that future utopia.

But I don't think that's the case anymore than the narrative that LLMs will eventually displace all software engineers.

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by ggreer on Monday September 21, 2026 @11:55AM (#49788924)
The invention of the automobile didn't eliminate all horses, but it certainly replaced the vast majority of horses.

In 7 years we've gone from GPT-2 to Fable and Astra. There seems to be no sign of slowdown, except from the top AI labs who want to slow down out of caution. It would be incredibly surprising to me if in another 7 years, my software engineering skills were still useful. AI capabilities will get to the point where even the best human is adding noise to the system, similar to today's chess engines and calculators.

Self-driving cars will take longer to roll out because they require new hardware and changes to laws, but I don't see how a career such as "truck driver" or "cab driver" exists in 20 years. At most it would be for a few niche uses and tourism novelty (similar to steam locomotives or horse-drawn buggies).

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by htrp on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:10PM (#49789169)
>It would be incredibly surprising to me if in another 7 years, my software engineering skills were still useful

This profession has always required reskilling/ changing based on new technologies. How many people are still meaningfully employed as pascal programmers?

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by ggreer on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:46PM (#49789722)
Almost every career requires staying on top of new developments to remain competitive. Even mechanics must learn about new systems in vehicles to be able to repair them. Not many people are still meaningfully employed as Model T mechanics.

The difference with LLMs is that they are a substitute for more general cognitive skills. Right now they are also a complement (using them increases the productivity of humans writing software), but it's only a matter of time before they improve to the point where they fully substitute. And it seems quite likely that the timeline for that is significantly shorter than my remaining career.

If you are confident that there will be specific tasks that LLMs can't accomplish in 2033, I'm happy to entertain such ideas. But considering the current rate of progress, I can't think of anything like that.

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by jlongr on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @09:24AM (#49800915)
> it's only a matter of time

Is it, though?

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by eru on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:04PM (#49789038)
I mostly agree. However, I do actually think that many of the skills you use as a software engineer will still be useful in 7 years. It's just that, as you suggest, no one will let us near any actual code.
Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by jlongr on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @09:20AM (#49800844)
I'm talking about drivers, not horses. EVs are slowly displacing gas cars but that's quite different than human drivers becoming obsolete.
Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by eru on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:02PM (#49789012)
Self-driving cars and trucks will eliminate human-controlled driving in the same way that engines (ICE, electric, steam, whatever) have eliminated human and animal powered transportation.

Yes, there are a few people around who ride horses, have an ox-cart or pedal their own bikes, but in a commercial sense, those are rounding errors.

Compilers have already replaced software engineers producing native code by hand. (Apart from a handful of exceptions.) LLMs will and do have a similar impact one level higher.

I'm really, really happy when I see my less technical friends suddenly vibe-code things they have dreamed up!

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by throwaway85825 on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:07PM (#49789101)
And when will the self driving car be able to orthogonal park a trailer by backing down and alley?
Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by eru on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:13PM (#49789214)
I don't know what that means. But presumably you are talking about some difficult technical feat that one can perform with a vehicle?

I'm fairly sure, if it's something mechanical and a human can do it, the computers won't be far behind. But even if not, we can redesign the vehicles to make it easier for a computer, eg we can make all axes or even all wheels independently steerable and control their velocity individually. A human would be overwhelmed with that, they can barely keep hold of a steering wheel, but a computer wouldn't mind too much.

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by throwaway85825 on Monday September 21, 2026 @12:40PM (#49789621)
Not difficult just an edge case with a more questionable value proposition for implementation.

Yes I considered independent wheels but a basic trailer is $3k, which doesn't leave much room for anything complicated.

The point is there's a million of these edge cases for which autonomy will not economically compete for another hundred years.

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by eru on Monday September 21, 2026 @10:23PM (#49796088)
Have a look at how the shipping container took over global logistics. They also had to redesign nearly everything about that industry, but the savings and efficiency gains were too juice to ignore.

> The point is there's a million of these edge cases for which autonomy will not economically compete for another hundred years.

My prediction: anything a human can do by just manipulating the controls of the car (steering wheel, gas, breaks) will be automated fairly quickly. Especially stuff like parking maneuvers (I assume that's what you describe?), because those happen at low speeds and mostly involve fixed non-moving obstacles. And it's pretty easy to generate training data. When the autonomous system attempts these edge cases, they can simulate a myriad attempts with the on-board computer. There's not a lot of physics going on at low speeds. (Or rather, pretty simple approximations are enough.)

The harder parts are dealing with moving and ambiguous objects (pedestrians, other cars, cyclists etc) at speed. But the industry is well aware of that.

About what will take longer: at the moment a truck driver provides a lot of incidental labour around the truck. Like helping with loading and unloading, minor repairs, etc.

If you have no person on board, you need to redesign how the industry is organised. If you need human help to unload at the destination, you need to preposition a human there, you can't rely on the truck coming with a human.

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by throwaway85825 on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @07:09AM (#49799362)
The logo of shopping lines is painted on co tainers because they own them. Cars on the other hand are owned by people. Millions of people own cars and may never switch go a self driving model. The average age of a car on the road keeps climbing because the quality of new cars is worse.

I'd like to see cars with better autonomy features but theyre still far too expensive and non standardized. When the computer breaks or needs an upgrade the whole car is junked. The purchase data shows people aren't asking for autonomy.

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by eru on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @08:53PM (#49810288)
> The average age of a car on the road keeps climbing because the quality of new cars is worse.

Huh, what? Cars are getting better and better and last longer; that's why the average age of a car on the road keeps climbing.

Where I lived the average car has been about the same age for a few decades now. They are all really new.

> The logo of shopping lines is painted on containers because they own them.

Only some of the have a logo painted on them. (I happen to live within a five minute walk to a container port in Singapore.)

> I'd like to see cars with better autonomy features but theyre still far too expensive and non standardized.

Yes, this will get better.

Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by jlongr on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @09:22AM (#49800874)
People replying to me keep confounding human-controlled transportation with the transpo tech itself. Yes horse and buggy is long gone. But human-controlled transportation is still here, over the course of driving horses, gas cars, and now EVs.
Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by eru on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @08:49PM (#49810257)
We had trains without drivers on board for ages. Lifts also lost their attendants; and some buildings here in Singapore don't have controls inside the lift.
Re:Uber arbitration award over Emily Normandin-Parker's death by jlongr on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @10:30AM (#49816773)
Those are not personal road-going vehicles.