It's a very comfortable way to ride (on flat country) and I prefer it for non-hipster reasons (i.e. my back).
Here in Chicago, people realized many years ago that road bikes with tiny, crack-seeking wheels, rigid suspension, aggressive posture and delicate derailleurs made horrible utility bikes.
So people first started appropriating mountain bikes, adding fenders, racks, new saddles etc. Then people discovered that old Schwinn three-speeds make perfect utility bikes without any conversion.
Now, yes, bike manufacturers have responded by building purpose-built utility bikes.
If you like road bikes then that's great. I actually love riding a road bike from time to time. 99% of the time I'm on a "granny bike" though, and if I weren't for those trips I'd be in a car.
I call my '96 Camry a "grandpa car". (In part because my grandfather owned it before I did.) I'm not sure it's as derisive as you think.
Thank you.
It is just describing a different style, those seeking comfort more than speed. Nothing wrong with that.
A lot of guys are also now spending ridiculous amount of money on hand made bikes just like the wealthy Chinese in the article.
The interesting thing is that for women the fashion has been more towards going for old wrecks also known as grandma bikes. See http://www.copenhagencyclechic.com