News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stallman: Thousands Dead, Millions Deprived of Liberties ... by beedeebeedee on Sunday September 20, 2026 @05:20PM (#49780184)
You've made several dubious claims. I'm honest and humble enough to be self-critical and not claim beyond what the deposition said, but that doesn't mean I should be held to a higher standard than you (i.e., if you did what you are demanding of me, you would have already apologized several times).

You are claiming there is no difference in the defense by the widow (who said she was always with him), while also claiming that Minsky was offered but declined. Both can only be the true if the offer was discreetly made and that the widow did not notice. The consequence is that it diminishes her as a reliable witness and also raises the question if the offer was discreet, couldn't it have been just as discreetly accepted?

If we accept your insider knowledge, it does not improve the circumstances. Not just because friends and colleagues would want to defend someone they are involved with (and indirectly, themselves), but also because the issue here is not just whether he participated, but why didn't he respond appropriately?

He was an intellectual leader. Shouldn't we demand our leaders to be moral? In a slightly better world, he would have had the moral clarity of Norm Finkelstein and rejected any association with Epstein once he was offered sex by a 17 year old under his care. It does not appear that Minsky did that, likely because he did not want to risk the grant money and perks of hob-knobbing with the wealthy, or risk reputational harm that Epstein could have inflicted to discredit him.

I will share a more ambiguous situation to make it clearer why Minsky's response was problematic. I had a friend at a Zen center when two young women came to visit. One of them was wealthy, and the other was nominally her friend but behaved like a servant. The wealthy one even directed her to have sex with some of the male students and other visitors. It was disturbing to my friend, and at the time, he was not sure how to respond. One could claim that the young woman who was being directed was benefitting from the relationship, and that, after all, she was an adult.

However it is clear that it is toxic behavior, even if the young woman's victimhood might seem ambiguous to some. I would claim that the behavior should be rebuked and that morality should not just be about protecting the victims you see but also about rebuking malevolence, because there are so many victims that are not seen. The wealthy young woman was exhibiting her character, and that character would likely persist whether it was in a relationship with her friend, children, or other vulnerable people. She should be plainly told that it is not ok.

Although I think some of your assessments are misguided, I think we have common ground about scape-goating (which you were referencing in the second half of your response, but didn't name). If Minsky had rebuked Epstein, or if my friend had rebuked that young woman, it is likely that both would have been scape-goated. Malicious people do not bind themselves to morality so they can lie, instigate and conspire to undermine the reputation of whistle-blowers and other truth speakers. This is a persistent problem of humanity that was exemplified by the stories of Socrates and Jesus, and all of free-thinkers killed during the European medieval period, Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. It is a problem even in much more mundane settings, and will occur whenever a moral person confronts immoral leadership. That is why we have to trumpet morality, lend support to moral behavior and speak out against abuse.

I'm not advocating for Minsky to be condemned as a terrible person. I'm just pointing out that he, as an example of wide-spread societal behavior, did not do the right thing.

Re:Stallman: Thousands Dead, Millions Deprived of Liberties ... by blagie on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @05:40AM (#49798625)
> You are claiming there is no difference in the defense by the widow (who said she was always with him), while also claiming that Minsky was offered but declined. Both can only be the true if the offer was discreetly made and that the widow did not notice.

This doesn't seem like rocket science. If I am e.g. at a dinner party with my spouse, I might be aware there was no opportunity to have sex while not monitoring every conversation my spouse is involved with.

Conversely, if someone flirts with my spouse, and my spouse doesn't engage, I might not take notice, or if I do, I might not find it important enough to report back. There's a broad space of possibilities. "Offered," in this context, is pretty broad.

Famous people have such "offers" all the time. I was once mildly famous, and in one place I visited, there was a person who clearly expressed interest, who looked perhaps half my age. I signed an autograph and quickly moved on. This is the first time I even thought to even relay the story.

> Not just because friends and colleagues would want to defend someone they are involved with...

... you have paranoid delusions. That's just not how the world works.

> If Minsky had rebuked Epstein

I have no evidence this did not happen, and neither do you. Most times, such rebukes are private. I also have no idea what, if anything, Minsky knew.

> rejected any association

> I'm not advocating for Minsky to be condemned as a terrible person. I'm just pointing out that he, as an example of wide-spread societal behavior, did not do the right thing.

You have no idea what he did. You picked a random person, and decided to vilify him in your brain, based on fragmentary quotes.

I'll also mention: Good people associate with bad people. Christians often cite how Jesus associated with tax collectors, sex workers, and other sinners. As a tactic, isolation does not work. Overcoming racism means associating with racists. Overcoming sexism means associating with sexists. "Talking with" is not the same as "supporting," and if we didn't have cancel culture or "cut diplomatic relations" as a punishment, the world would be a much better place.

Re:Stallman: Thousands Dead, Millions Deprived of Liberties ... by beedeebeedee on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @10:51AM (#49802316)
> > Not just because friends and colleagues would want to defend someone they are involved with...

> ... you have paranoid delusions. That's just not how the world works.

Your brain is cooked if you’re going to deny that and resort to insults and other nonsense again

Re:Stallman: Thousands Dead, Millions Deprived of Liberties ... by blagie on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @07:40AM (#49814559)
Your brain is cooked if you write:

> I will back down from my claim that Minsky did have sex with Virginia Giuffree

And then continue to argue basing your arguments on that "fact." You have some kind of vendetta. It's not grounded in evidence, and you're willing to contort facts around that vendetta.

And you write things like:

> if you did what you are demanding of me, you would have already apologized several times

What I'm asking you to do is to not spread baseless accusations, especially about someone who can't defend themselves because they passed away.

The people you should apologize to aren't myself, but the people whom you slandered.

What do I have to apologize for, in your mind?

Re:Stallman: Thousands Dead, Millions Deprived of Liberties ... by beedeebeedee on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @11:55AM (#49818022)
Yikes, please stop. It doesn't matter if Minsky did or did not accept her offer. Please re-read my comments (and your own).

We've gone over this several times. You have not discussed this in good faith. I won't respond to you again about this.

Re:Stallman: Thousands Dead, Millions Deprived of Liberties ... by beedeebeedee on Tuesday September 22, 2026 @02:21PM (#49805841)
I can't edit my last comment but want to address the rest of your response even if it has become clear that you are not discussing this in good faith.

> > Not just because friends and colleagues would want to defend someone they are involved with...

> ... you have paranoid delusions. That's just not how the world works.

This is absolutely how the world works. Notice I did not say only. There usually will be a cohort that will immediately try to distance themselves, but also a cohort that will defend. The ratio will be different in different circumstances. You are denying the defending cohort while you are clearly part of it (if we believe your prior statements about your closeness to the situation). That is absurd.

What is further absurd is that you are comparing Minksy and Epstein to Jesus's ministry amongst the poor and marginalized. I am not sure how to respond to that. I did not know Minksy but I can assure you he was much more likely thinking about his grant money and protecting his own reputation (and MIT's) than being Christ-like to Epstein.

What you are talking about is enabling: ignoring morality. Once again, I'll state that that is not ok, and admonish Minksy for his own actions, as well as understanding that why we do this as a society is also to remind each other of what should be ok and what should not be ok. You seem to want to say that Minksy's association with Epstein was ok. I disagree. Let's leave it at that.