Re:If math is more than proof, we need to better celebrate t...
by sweezyjeezy on Saturday September 19, 2026 @07:59AM
(#49765822)
Broadly I agree with this, but I was refuting the statement "there has never been a better time to be a mathematician". You are changing the question to something different here, and using it to say my argument is bad.
I think math is a microcosm for "thought-work" in general. We have been in a symbiotic relationship with capitalism for decades now, where the hope of a well-paid white collar career encourages people to take on debt to enrich themselves through education. The proliferation of AI cheating at college signals that this is the primary goal, so one imagines it only gets worse if the labor market's demand simply disappears.
It's hard to say where this all leads, but I have very low optimism for higher-level math understanding being something that humans value in the same way in the coming decades.
The concerning argument about the status of math would be an outline that it will get destroyed by a process of societal atrophy and there is no turning back, and the AI powers are not a good substitute or replacement for it. If an entire society becomes reliant on these oracle machines then it would be analogous to children never learning arithmetic because they were handed calculators. How could the human race still flourish? We would anthropologically regress. We'd be little better than animals, like the Borg zombies.
That is a much more profound threat than people worrying about their own careers or faculties disappearing like the humanities. This is a serious anthropological reckoning.
If math experts are that freaked out already then basically all of science is soon to follow, decade by decade. "Singularity" comes to mind.