The issue Yglesias seems to have with that is that the market can profit from volatility even if, over the long term, Amazon's actions are a net negative for the larger economy, and would fail without their intervention.
I don't know how much of that I buy. I'm just pointing out the hugely privileged position Amazon has.
Its like grinding in poker, once your bankroll is much bigger then all the other players combined it is a forgone conclusion that you'll win it all if you play correctly.
This sort of thing is inevitable and why you have Walmart and Tesco for example. Mature industries settle around a few outsized players.
Royalty clubs like Amazon Prime are obviously the end game. They won't go broke, they'll become the single most important account for many millions of households.
As i see it , their strategy is simple: identify the points along e-commerce where monopolies/quasi-monopolies can be formed and control them.
So they try to control the customer, the data, the warehouses, the marketing(the digital experience), the volume and now the financing.
My guess is, due to all those, e-commerce's end-game is a winner takes most market.
If they'll have monopoly powers, destroying everybody's profits(and everybody) wouldn't matter much. At that point amazon could increase prices and profits.
Luckily for smaller businesses, they can compete with Amazon and other big box retailers on that front, but they're still learning how to use/leverage the tools the big guys have been using for years.
This is one I will definitely leave for the smart investors.
Yglesias has an even more sinister theory: that there's no real rhyme or reason to Amazon's strategy, that it's acting on the assumption that having beaten the market into submission there will somehow, in some way, be a way for Amazon to capitalize on the resulting chaos --- but that it's equally likely that Amazon will itself crater, having destroyed everyone's profits in the process.
I like Amazon (we're Prime subscribers), but I have to bear that in mind every time I prepare myself to complain about Wal Mart (which I do not like).
In any case: it's close to impossible for a small-scale retailer to compete with Amazon once Amazon decides it's competing.