News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of l... by cluckindan on Friday September 18, 2026 @07:41AM (#49752943)
A lot of sites have terms and conditions which explicitly disallow the use of site content as a part of another service.

If I have a bike and you start renting it out without my permission, surely you are committing theft of some sort.

If I build a complex custom bike and you start copying individual features from it on your custom bikes, surely you are committing theft of some sort, but whether it’s punishable depends on whether I’ve decided to go full corporate and protect my designs with patents and trademarks. You’ll be hard pressed to patent or trademark anything if I have published and documented prior art.

Re:Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of l... by pbasista on Friday September 18, 2026 @08:18AM (#49753319)
> A lot of sites have terms and conditions which explicitly disallow the use of site content as a part of another service.

Having terms and conditions in itself is irrelevant. Because in order for them to have any legal meaning, it is necessary for the other party to agree to them.

An agreement can be implicitly enforced by law. Or explicitly enforced by the website itself before giving access to the data. If neither of those are present, there is no enforced agreement. And agreeing to it becomes optional. Such sites should be considered, in my opinion, publicly accessible.

> If I have a bike and you start renting it out without my permission, surely you are committing theft of some sort.

Of course. But that is a bad analogy. No one is "renting" or "taking" anything from those websites. The bots are just reading it.

Therefore, a better analogy would be that you have a bike, parked out in the public, and people are looking at it. By looking at it they steal nothing from you. And the bike and all of its parts remain yours at all times. That is a suitable analogy, in my opinion, to what those bots are doing.

Re:Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of l... by Anamon on Thursday September 24, 2026 @01:30PM (#49834028)
That's not true. Copyright applies whether the author says so or not. By default, anything you find on the publicly accessible web, you are NOT free to reuse.

That's why the GenAI companies try to talk their way out by claiming training is "Fair Use". It means they acknowledge that the materials they use are copyrighted and not legal to reproduce without a license.

Re:Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of l... by Ylpertnodi on Friday September 18, 2026 @10:54AM (#49755283)
> If I have a bike and you start renting it out without my permission, surely you are committing theft of some sort.

Where is the loss? Apart from trust?