News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why We Should All Care About Today's Senate Vote on FISA by Spooky23 on Thursday December 27, 2012 @02:24PM (#4974678)
Given the fact that most of these things are done in near-total secrecy, how can you be sure that the "systemic overcollection" concern is what you say it is?

And what is a "purely domestic" communication in this context? Is this message board a domestic communication? A telephone call? A telephone call to a foreign national living in the US? I have no idea. How would I prove that it is or isn't?

I'm not some sort of paranoid that thinks that the government is out to get me. I do know that for routine criminal matters, the Federal government has incredibly broad and effective police powers, even with court oversight. Pre-9/11, the government was already able to gather lots of actionable information about the threat our nation was about to face (and fumbled the ball).

So I'm not convinced that all of this secrecy and lack of accountability is buying me anything as a citizen. Frankly, I'm concerned that by mindlessly gathering vast swaths of data, it will become exponentially more difficult to extract signal from the noise.

Re:Why We Should All Care About Today's Senate Vote on FISA by tptacek on Thursday December 27, 2012 @05:25PM (#4975385)
If the concern is that the executive is hiding facts from the legislative or judicial branches: those branches can appoint special prosecutors, independent counsels, or whatever it is you want to call them. There's obviously no foolproof mechanism by which anyone can absolutely ensure that the President or his team or the DoD will divulge information, but there are facilities the branches can use to hold each other accountable.
Re:Why We Should All Care About Today's Senate Vote on FISA by m0nastic on Thursday December 27, 2012 @06:47PM (#4975703)
I participated in one such example of this oversight (most fun test I ever did).

We were hired by a Special Master that Congress appointed to conduct a pen test against a branch of the DoI without their knowledge[1]

[1] As part of this class action: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobell_vs._Salazar