How should we define "legal productivity"? I think that it should be measured by making victims whole and CMU was not deprived of anything by Marvell using the same pattern. The focus on arbitrary jail time and fines paid to government versus restoring victims is one thing which needs to be rebooted.
Another is the tragedy of the commons situation with free and open access to courts. This creates a long queue for trials and simply drawing out a case which has no merit is used as a weapon itself. If justice was a service being paid for and we implement a loser-pays doctrine, as has always been the case in common law, we wouldn't see a lot of these patent cases, besides the fact that IP cannot exist without a state to grant the monopoly.
> CMU was not deprived of anything by Marvell using the same pattern
CMU was deprived of a reasonable royalty under the law. What does being made whole mean if not being granted what the law guarantees?
> The focus on arbitrary jail time and fines paid to government versus restoring victims is one thing which needs to be rebooted.
This has nothing to do with patent cases. Are you saying criminal law also needs a reboot?
> If justice was a service being paid for and we implement a loser-pays doctrine, as has always been the case in common law, we wouldn't see a lot of these patent cases, besides the fact that IP cannot exist without a state to grant the monopoly.
I have no idea what you're trying to get at here. Loser-pays has some advantages, but it also has some serious disadvantages. As for IP requiring a state to grant the monopoly, I don't think anyone has ever claimed otherwise, and it has nothing to do with loser-pays. I'm just confused by your comment.
There Are so many laws it is impossible to know if you are breaking one or not.
http://unclibertarians.com/are-you-breaking-the-law/
Laws are designed by committee. We know how that works out for programming projects.
I think the volume of laws could be significantly reduced and laws could be simplified, but the law making process doesn't allow it.
Ianal.