News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by moe on Thursday December 27, 2012 @02:56AM (#4972742)
Since my other comment got downvoted for unknown reasons I'll attach the WARNING here again:

Be aware that Inky uploads your imap password to their servers (see their FAQ). This is probably due to incompetence rather than malice but if you care about your e-mail password you should refrain from installing this software. If you have already entered your imap password into Inky you should change it ASAP.

Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by pqs on Thursday December 27, 2012 @03:44AM (#4972811)
The password is encrypted client side!
Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by moe on Thursday December 27, 2012 @05:18AM (#4972944)
That's meaningless. It opens a whole range of attack vectors for absolutely reason. No least your inky password (which they presumably use as the key). They allow a minimum length of 6 chars on that, which can be brute forced within hours on todays hardware.

They very clearly have no idea what they're doing (security-wise), consequently this is very likely not the only fatal flaw in their implementation.

Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by cuu508 on Thursday December 27, 2012 @05:38AM (#4972967)
Easy account sync between devices is a good enough reason for me. It can be implemented securely, so in general I don't see a problem. Hey, Google Chrome syncs saved passwords, online password vaults like LastPass do this too, are they security-incompetent too? Don't know what hash function and encryption they use, but I think it's possible to pick/configure them so that brute-forcing even 6-character passwords is impractical.
Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by moe on Thursday December 27, 2012 @06:55AM (#4973054)
If you're willing to gamble your imap password on their undocumented process then that's fine.

I posted my warning because I think most users are not even aware that they're sending their password to inky and the implied risk. Also inky does nothing to educate them (a handwavy marketing-blurb buried in the FAQ does not count).

Sorry but comparing inky to LastPass and Google is laughable. Google is trusted because it's Google. LastPass is trusted because their process is extensively documented. If you plan to casually juggle your users crown jewels for a convenience-feature then you'd better fit into one of these two categories.

Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by cuu508 on Thursday December 27, 2012 @07:23AM (#4973096)
Yep, the process needs to be transparent, documented and verifiable. Until it is, good idea to warn others!
Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by mike-cardwell on Thursday December 27, 2012 @07:17AM (#4973089)
Client side encryption is only useful when the application is open source. Otherwise, we've no idea if there is a back door in the application and a signal that their servers can send back to the client to inform it to send over all of your login details.

Hushmail were forced by their government to backdoor their system for this purpose. What's stopping the same thing from happening to Inky?

Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by alexmuller on Thursday December 27, 2012 @04:03AM (#4972837)
Right, but they also store the decryption key -- your Inky password. Which is (presumably?) encrypted… somehow? Maybe?
Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by jtheory on Friday December 28, 2012 @07:34PM (#4980387)
This would be nice to know, because they're serving as a password-management app for all of your email passwords.

Presumably, they would not store your Inky password as well -- instead, they'd store a secure hash, not MD5 or SHA-1, which are built for speed, not security....

Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by dmbaggett on Saturday December 29, 2012 @09:10AM (#4982101)
It's more complicated than that. Please see my comments on security elsewhere in the thread. We store a password verifier object -- that's akin to a secure hash, but our authentication model offers better guarantees about protection from man-in-the-middle attacks.
Re:Desktop App for All Your Email by dmbaggett on Thursday December 27, 2012 @08:39AM (#4973253)
See my comments on security elsewhere in the thread.